There is a fundamental and serious problem with both the Big Bang Theory and with evolution. To explain what that problem is and why I think it exists, I must take you back to 1992 and the most important bubble bath I ever had. I was reading a very basic book about quantum

mechanics. I can't remember exactly what page I was on or what I was thinking at the time, but I do remember the moment that I arrived in this universe. You see, before that bath, I was living in a very different place, where surprisingly little made sense, a place where nobody

really knew anything and a place where no truth at all could ever be found. Then, in what seemed like a second, something changed inside, but everything outside looked different, more real, more interesting. I couldn't think of anything that wasn't interesting. The colors on the surfaces of the

bubbles in the bath were mesmerizing to me. I remember giggling as I realized that I knew why those colors were there. For the first time in my life, I didn't feel like a fool. A few years later, a friend turned to me after watching an episode of

Cosmos by Carl Sagan. She was crying. She looked confused and angry for a few seconds. I didn't understand, and then she asked me the saddest question I ever heard. But it was a question I instantly remembered asking myself over and over

back in that bubble bath. And a few years after this, I'm on the phone to my girlfriend and we're talking about special relativity. That's right, I know what the lady's like when there's this sudden and prolonged silence on the

other end of the line and the next thing I hear is that same question again. I can't tell if she's laughing or crying, it sounds like both. So on three occasions, I've been present when somebody caught a glimpse of the universe, not through a telescope, but

with their mind. Photos are beautiful and revealing that the nature and scale of the cosmos are not things you can see with your eyes. They can only be seen, and even then only partially and fleetingly, in your mind, and only then after you've learned enough.

Sadly, there aren't that many people who've experienced it compared to the number that could actually experience it, and fewer still have seen it happen to others. It doesn't make me an expert, but I think it's at least interesting, with all three experiences, I have

similarities. It can only be called a revelation. It happens suddenly, without any warning, and it doesn't last long. Maybe you'll just be daydreaming when out of nowhere a new realization comes to you that explains something you never understood before, that in turn explains

something else that explains something else that explains something else that explains something else. An understanding simply comes into view. The Sun will never be just the Sun again, and you'll understand why people say that minds connect. Span, it's the only word for it.

You won't really know why you're laughing, and that too will be funny. It's like you know a big secret, and it was all just too easy and too obvious in the end. Everything fits, everything makes crystal-clear sense, everything flows into everything else, and the gaps that

are supernatural Gods used to occupy with plenty of room to spare will evaporate any shred of religiously instilled fear, guilt, or shame will vanish utterly in that second you never imagined it was possible only now do you know that it is just as you know you

will never believe a holy book ever again you'll understand that science will never be complete but that'll be okay what else would tomorrow hold but then comes a kind of anger in the form of that question why didn't anybody tell me how could it be that the answers were

there all along just a few books away and I didn't know why did I have to waste all those years thinking it was all a mystery how could I get out of school and not know that the Big Bang almost certainly happened why couldn't I live in that universe all

along what else is school for if not to teach kids what we know about how things are why weren't people yelling at me screaming at my stupidity and ignorance so much is known and I didn't know why didn't anybody tell me three times I was there and three times

that the first question asked afterwards at the time I thought the answer was simple bad schools about teachers but now I think I know better it's just not true that nobody told us the people that knew were telling us all along the question is not why didn't

anyone tell us but rather why couldn't we hear and while it's true that the truth can get lost in this world of  and stupidity I think there's a far bigger problem even for the courageously honest and rational this reality we find ourselves in the

Big Bang, the emergence and evolution of life and love from atoms, and those four and a half billion summers on Earth. Without Earth, and then we come along, possibly the only minds in the cosmos contemplating the sunrise for hundreds of millennia, yearning to understand the universe, only to find out to our

surprise that we are the universe, but our atoms were once at the core of a star, and before that we were the energy cascading from a quantum event that we may never understand. Isn't that the very definition of incredible, literally incredible? And that's the problem I think the

reality itself is simply too unbelievable, too hard to accept on an instinctive level. What an astonishing situation to find ourselves in! Reality is unbelievably unbelievable, so unbelievable that for many, religion is actually easier to believe. How unbelievable is that? But there is a way

to be free of confusion and so much of your doubt and to step into a universe that makes sense. If you want to paraphrase Einstein, cosmology without atomic theory is lame, an atomic theory without cosmology is blind, and evolution without either of them is only

a third of what you need to understand. Anyone who knows anything about how a car works sees a car more completely than a non-mechanic who just sees the surface. And so it is with the universe. You won't get it if you only know about the spark plugs and the battery and the

steering wheel. That ain't a car, but at some point as you learn about the major components and their relationships and interdependencies, then in your mind you see a car in a way that eyes can't. And if this happens for you with the universe, this is how it will be.

I can only say what it's like, it's like you've only ever eaten okay but dry doughnuts. You know, when you encounter a good one, if you are to take one thought away from this video, let it be this: there is an awful lot of jam in the

doughnut of truth. It's like knowing, or rather like knowing that you probably know, like you know, you thought you knew, but now you know you know. Probably... would you read that back to me? I'm afraid that might make me sound pompous to your

Why Didn't Anybody Tell Me?

philhellenes

개인 계시와 기존 이론의 문제점

연사는 빅뱅 이론과 진화에 대한 근본적인 문제를 소개합니다.

발표자는 1992년에 겪은 혁신적인 경험을 설명하며 이를 이해의 전환과 연관시킵니다.

연사는 이 경험이 우주에 대한 인식에 미친 심오한 영향에 대해 자세히 설명합니다.

화자는 친구 및 여자 친구와의 비슷한 경험을 이야기하며 이 계시의 공유된 특성을 강조합니다.

연사는 이러한 이해의 희귀성과 습득한 지식에 대한 의존성을 강조합니다.

화자는 갑작스럽고 예상치 못한 짧은 계시의 성격을 설명합니다.

계시는 다양한 개념을 연결하여 계단식으로 이해하는 것이 특징입니다.

화자는 이해, 기쁨, 분노의 감정을 포함하여 이 계시의 감정적, 지적 영향을 묘사합니다.

이 계시는 이전에 초자연적인 믿음으로 채워졌던 공백을 없애줍니다.

화자는 이러한 이해를 더 빨리 듣지 못한 것에 대해 분노를 표현합니다.

연사는 이러한 지식을 전달하는 데 있어 교육의 역할에 대해 질문합니다.

화자는 나쁜 학교가 책임이 있다는 초기의 믿음을 반성하고 다른 이해로 전환합니다.

화자는 의사소통의 부족이 문제가 아니라 메시지를 듣지 못하는 것이 문제라고 말합니다.

연사는 빅뱅과 진화, 우주에서 우리의 위치가 본능적으로 받아들이기에는 너무 놀라운 현실이라는 생각을 소개합니다.

연사는 우리가 원자와 별, 양자 사건을 연결하는 우주라는 놀라운 사실을 강조합니다.

연사는 현실의 믿을 수 없는 특성 때문에 많은 사람들이 종교를 더 쉽게 믿게 된다고 제안합니다.

연사는 우주론, 원자론, 진화의 상호 연관성을 이해함으로써 혼란과 의심을 극복할 수 있는 방법을 제시합니다.

연사는 우주에 대한 총체적인 이해의 필요성을 설명하기 위해 자동차를 이해하는 비유를 사용합니다.

연사는 완전한 이해를 위해서는 주요 구성 요소와 그 상호 관계에 대한 지식이 필요하다고 강조합니다.

연사는 우주에 대한 총체적인 이해를 얻는 변화의 경험을 설명합니다.

화자는 잼이 가득한 도넛의 은유를 사용하여 풍부한 지식과 이해가 가능하다는 것을 표현합니다.

화자는 이 경험을 통해 얻은 지식의 확실성에 대해 반성합니다.

Why Didn't Anybody Tell Me?

Why Didn't Anybody Tell Me?

스크립트