Another example I like here is Sam Harris. He's a great example of a guy who's stuck on content. He's really stuck on harping on the content of Islam and on the content of religion overall because he's built an identity out of

being a rationalist. That's his whole shtick. That's his whole career and it's his whole, his whole ego is about that. But in, in being so wrapped up and so critical of the content of Islam, he misses the deeper structural problems which are really the

the cause of terrorism and problems in the Middle East. So Sam Harris likes to attribute terrorism and Islamism and all this sort of stuff to what is written in the Quran. And his idea is that well, the Quran is a particularly bad religious book.

Yes, the Bible is bad, but the Quran is worse because it's more violent. The actual content in the Quran encourages violence. That's his sort of argument. And the problem with that is, is that that really misses the point. The thing that's really running the show

that's responsible for terrorism and radical uh Islamists doing bad stuff is low cognitive, moral, and spiritual development on the spiral which of course is prevalent in the Middle East. And the reason it's prevalent in the Middle East is not because of the Quran. It's because

of a long chain of historical, geopolitical factors that go back thousands of years, um, which are independent of the content of the Quran and simply because their spiral development hasn't been given enough time to rise to stage orange or green or

yellow or turquoise. Most of the Middle East, many of the poorest countries in the Middle East are still stuck in Spiral Dynamics purple and red, and maybe if they're developed, blue, and like if they really developed a little bit of orange, but mostly it's

a lot of purple and red. Still a lot of tribalism going on there, but you know, this has to do with a lot of geopolitical factors. It has to do with the temperature, the climate that they live in. It has to do with, uh, the geography, the mountain ranges, it has

to do with the animals that live there. It has to do with the farming, the agriculture. There's so many factors, so to reduce all this to, to, to bad phrases within the Quran is, is quite ridiculous. It ignores the historical context, it ignores the structure of

Spiral Dynamics. It ignores the problems of ideology in general. The problems of Islam are not limited to the Quran or to the Islam. These are general well-known ideological problems. These are basically, this is basically cult psychology at work. Cult psychology is at work not only in

Islam, it's, it's at work in America, in Christianity, but not just in Christianity, in science. So while Sam Harris is overly focused on Islam, he's missing the structural similarities between Islam and Christianity and science and atheism

and himself, which is of course the whole point of what he's doing, because the whole point is to separate himself and his culture and his ideology from that of Islam and to put his own on top. That's the whole underlying, never spoken or admitted agenda, which is fueling everything he's

doing of course none of this can ever be admitted because to admit it you'd have to go very meta just to see it and it would be very painful to admit that, probably ruin his career, so it's not in his interest to admit that.

Why Sam Harris Is Wrong About Religion & Islam

Actualized Clips

이슬람의 내용에 대한 샘 해리스의 초점

샘 해리스는 이슬람과 종교의 콘텐츠에 집착하며 합리주의자로서 자신의 정체성과 경력을 쌓아가고 있습니다.

해리스는 콘텐츠에 집중함으로써 테러리즘과 중동의 문제를 야기하는 더 깊은 구조적 문제를 간과하고 있습니다.

해리스는 꾸란의 내용이 성경보다 더 폭력적이라고 주장하며 테러리즘의 원인을 꾸란의 내용에서 찾습니다.

테러리즘은 낮은 인지적, 도덕적, 영적 발달에서 비롯된다는 주장은 핵심을 놓치고 있습니다.

중동에서 저개발이 만연한 것은 꾸란 때문이 아니라 역사적, 지정학적 요인에 기인합니다.

많은 중동 국가들이 나선형 역학의 낮은 단계(보라색, 빨간색, 파란색)에 머물러 있어 주황색, 녹색 등으로의 발전이 부족합니다.

기후, 지리, 농업, 부족주의와 같은 요인이 이러한 상황에 영향을 미칩니다.

이 문제를 꾸란의 내용으로 축소하는 것은 역사적 맥락과 나선형 역학을 무시하는 것입니다.

이슬람을 넘어선 광범위한 이데올로기 문제

이슬람이나 꾸란에 국한된 문제가 아니라 일반적인 이데올로기 문제입니다.

컬트 심리학은 이슬람, 기독교, 과학, 무신론 등 다양한 종교에 존재합니다.

해리스는 이슬람에 초점을 맞추면서 서로 다른 이데올로기 간의 구조적 유사성을 간과하고 있습니다.

해리스의 행동은 자신의 이념과 이슬람을 분리하려는 인정되지 않은 의도에 의해 추진되고 있습니다.

Why Sam Harris Is Wrong About Religion & Islam

Why Sam Harris Is Wrong About Religion & Islam

스크립트