고독스 vs Profoto: 종합적인 플래시 스트로보 비교

Godox는 Profoto와 비슷한 성능을 훨씬 저렴한 가격에 제공하므로 사진가에게 현명한 선택이 될 것입니다.

### 고독스 AD600과 Profoto B10 Plus 비교: 종합적인 비교
* 📸 이 리뷰는 Godox AD600과 Profoto B10 Plus를 비교하며, Godox의 가격이 **$450**인 반면 Profoto는 약 **$2,000**로 **상당히 비싸다**고 강조합니다.
* 💰 Profoto가 사진 장비의 '롤스로이스'라는 명성에도 불구하고, 리뷰어는 Godox가 **비슷한 성능과 신뢰성을 **비싼 가격**으로 제공한다고 강조합니다.
* 🔋 고독스 AD600은 10년 동안 수많은 여행과 혹독한 환경을 견뎌낸 **견고함과 신뢰성**으로 유명하며, Profoto는 **사용의 편리함과 사용자 친화적인 인터페이스**로 찬사를 받고 있습니다.
* ⚖ 리뷰어는 색 품질 측면에서 "**고독스가 더 좋아 보인다**"며 고독스의 색 정확도와 성능이 Profoto와 비슷하다고 평가했습니다.
* 🔧 한 리뷰어는 "기본 리플렉터의 가격이 225달러인데 비해 고독스는 20달러"라고 언급하는 등 Profoto의 리플렉터는 가격이 비싸다는 비판을 받고 있습니다.
* 🛠 고독스 시스템은 표준 소프트박스와의 **호환성**으로 유명한 반면, Profoto의 내장 디퓨저는 **다양한 활용성**을 자랑합니다.
* 🖼 궁극적으로 리뷰어는 두 브랜드 모두 훌륭한 작품을 만들 수 있지만, 브랜드 명성보다는 **개인적 취향과 예산**에 따라 선택해야 한다고 결론지었습니다.
* 📅 리뷰어는 다음 동영상에서 **조명 수정자**에 대해 자세히 살펴볼 예정이라며 사진작가에게 **귀중한 통찰력을 제공할 것이라고 예고했습니다.

[Music] foreign ah this was inevitable profoto. All right, here we have two professional photography flash strobes. This is a Godox AD600/Explorer Flashpoint 600/450. This is a Profoto B10 Plus 500 watt-seconds. This is 600, that's a 500, 2,000. Let's compare, shall we? This to the photography world is the Rolls Royce. They say you're not professional if you don't use Profoto. This is what you must use in order to be the best. As you know, I can afford anything I want. I can afford as much of anything I want. So which one do I choose? Now you know me, I don't give a rat's ass what people think. Nobody gives me stuff for free to try. I don't have any company sponsoring me. I pay for everything. I don't even tell people I get it. I just secretly buy it and I play with it and I give you my true honest response. Now as you know, this is the original Godox AD600/Flashpoint Explorer 600. Same thing, they

just put a different brand on it anyway. This is the original one. You can get this one for 450 dollars. They have a new pro version, which is like 900 dollars, double the cost. I would not suggest getting the pro version. The only difference is it flashes a little faster. It's got a few little things here and there, but as far as power, it's the same exact power. The pro does not have one iota more power than this thing does. The flash color is the same, dependability is the same. It is just, I mean, get this one, 450 bucks. This is what I've used for the last 10 years. This has been around the world six times. This thing is so dependable and rugged. I love this thing. Now, I just got this thing because I'm about to go on a major trip halfway around the world, and luggage size and weight is kind of important. So, I wanted the smallest, most powerful thing that I could get. This is the 600, is kind of my standard for power. This thing is actually pretty close in

power. It's a 500, but if you tweak it, you can get it just about the same power level as this. I thought this is going to be about the same size as an ad300. It's a little bigger than that. Now I know the original b10 was around the size of a 300 here, but it was half the power. This is twice the power. Is this really that much smaller than this? And as far as weight goes, this is a little lighter, but it's still pretty heavy. This is like almost four and a half pounds. This one is a little over six pounds. So there's a two-pound difference with the battery. The actual flash doesn't weigh that much, actually. This is the weight difference. Look at the difference. This thing is three times the size and weight of this thing. This is a standard reflector. It goes on the Godox, 20 bucks. If you want a diffuser to go on that, you can buy the reflector and the diffuser for 28 bucks. The Profoto

version pretty much the same thing. 225 dollars for this plastic reflector. The new flash trigger is four hundred dollars. Everything Profoto makes is incredibly expensive. A 24 inch, basically two foot, was that 60 centimeter soft box, little tiny 60 centimeter soft softbox, 200. Oh, but wait, that's just the fabric. If you want the plastic speed ring that it goes on to hold it together, that's another hundred dollars. Welcome to the Profoto ecosystem. Everything costs ridiculous amounts of money. Now, I know Profoto is from Sweden and making things in Sweden is expensive. They have expensive taxes and then shipping it overseas and distribution and all that stuff and reselling fees. It raises it. I get that. And it is quality. This thing is a quality construction. It's like the Mercedes of cars. If you want performance, you get the same thing with this. If you want high quality and you don't want that plasticky feel and you want just little tiny things here and there, Profoto is the way to go. But seriously

As far as actual performance, this thing beats this thing. Israel, the color is actually... let me just show you some pictures. Here's a picture taken with the AD600. Here's the picture taken with the Profoto AD600. Profoto AD600. Profoto. Now, YouTube might change the colors a bit, but when I look at this on my color-calibrated computer, the Godox looks better. I like the colors better. That's just me. It's my taste. I worked in Hollywood for 25 years. I did color timing on my motion picture and deluxe labs. I'm an artist. My paintings have been in galleries all over the world. Color for me is my life. I see things that color meters and things can never see. It's very, very close. Most people can never tell the difference. I can tell the difference right away, but most people can't. Alright, so let's ask some basic questions. The 600 here, is it as powerful as this? It's more powerful. Is it color accurate? It's awesome. What's the recharge rate? It's faster than this. What about the

amount of flashes. It's got more. Is it dependable? Yes. Is it rugged? It's been in the most rugged situations imaginable. It's been in jungles. It's been on the top of a volcano. It's been in beaches. It's been in Death Valley at 120 degrees. This thing has been banged around in luggage and in the trunk of my car for 10 years, and it never fails me. This thing is super dependable, super rugged. I just love it. Okay, cost. This costs four times more than this. And now for modifiers. I mean, this is basic stuff here. I don't know why people don't bring this up, but notice the bulb sticks out on this one and does not on this one. This one has a built-in diffuser, which you cannot take off. Only the factory can take that off. You cannot expose the bulb. This bulb is recessed, and it's got a flat diffuser over it, and you're stuck with that. This is your bare bulb, and it does not stick out when you put it in a softbox. You want the bulb to

stick in freely so the light goes out and hits all the surfaces of the inside of the softbox. This is flush with the very edge of the softbox. There's nothing sticking in emitting bare light to all the inner silver surfaces of the softbox. Now, it still works. I mean, it still produces a good amount of light and all that, but I like it where the bulb sticks in freely inside your modifier. So, this is what you're stuck with. There's nothing you can do about it. Now, I gotta admit, I like the back here. It's really simple to use. They made this. The user interface is so easy. Look at this one to ten. You just dial in the number, the power you want. It's very simple. It's kind of like so simplified, and that's one thing I like about the elegance usage of this thing. They really made it easy and simple and fun to use. So, as far as fun to use and easy and all that, this Profoto has that down. So, as far as

brightness goes with these two. I put these reflectors on each one, and here's the test with the reflector on it. This is the Godox 600, and this is the Profoto. Now, let's stick a softbox on it. Let's do a Cheetah QSB 34. This is the Godox 600, and this is the Profoto. You can see in these pictures the Profoto is not as strong, but it's pretty close, so that's okay. I mean, it is a 500. This is a 600. What bothers me is the price. I mean, first of all, this isn't that much smaller. It really isn't. Look at these two together. The only thing you're paying for is the fact that it's a little better made and the user experience is a little better. I mean, come on. I mean, seriously, 450 dollars, 2,000, and that's before the modifiers. Profoto modifiers are not that great, especially the softboxes. I look at the comments that a lot of these

people leave the rods are poking through the fabric and stuff, and they're overpriced. Pro photo modifiers are so ridiculously overpriced. But you can get a Bowens mount adapter to stick on here. So now you have a Bowens mount that you can stick on this thing. Look at this big clunky thing that you got to put on there so you can put Bowens mount on there. Or you can use one of these things. And this is the plate that goes into any standard softbox. So here we have a standard softbox, just the Godox 2x3 foot softbox. And I put this thing on here. So now I can put my Profoto light onto any modifier that I want, or especially softbox or things like that. You don't have to use Profoto modifiers. So I've been putting these two head to head with each other, doing the exact same thing for a week. And really, I mean, this is a little smaller, not much. It's a little smaller, it's a little lighter. Is it a big difference?

not really. It's more fun to use the quality. The build quality is better. This is more plasticky. This is a Ferrari. This is a Ford Shelby GT. Just as fast, just as powerful, just handling is great. The interior is plasticky. This interior is custom made. It's great and all that, but would I spend the money now? As you know, I can afford anything. I have a Ferrari. I have a Lamborghini. I have a Jaguar F-Type. I can buy them new if I want, but I refuse to. Why? Because it's just insulting to have to spend money on something that is now. I know it's handmade, it's custom made. They don't make that many. I know it's a work of art and all that. You want to be the first one. It's been untouched and it's just... I get that, but now maybe the Jaguar I could buy new if I had to, but the other ones, it's just... This is how I feel about this. It's just

uh, even if you have the money. This is where I get into the rant. A lot of people are going to say, Yeah, but if you're a professional photographer, you need Profoto. This is the de facto standard. You will not be taken seriously unless you have Profoto. You cannot take great pictures until you only see a Profoto. I worked in Hollywood for 25 years, and I will tell you that, you know, those who say, You know, your clients will take you more seriously. They will give you, you will get more jobs if you have the professional equipment, for a few superficial clients, maybe. In all my years in Hollywood, people did not get hired because of the equipment they used. They got hired for the quality of the work that they did, how creative they were. I've seen people do masterpieces with very little low-end equipment. Leonardo da Vinci created masterpieces with a stick of charcoal, and the people that get hired to do jobs get hired because they do great work, and you can do great work with stuff that

doesn't cost much, and on the other hand, I have seen numerous Profoto users make the most boring, unprofessional-looking pictures using this super-expensive equipment. Now, a lot of people are going to say, Yeah, but it's rugged, and it lasts forever, and all that. This thing has been around the world six times. Like I said, it's been rattling around in the trunk of my car. It's been in luggage bags. I do not treat this gingerly, and it just works. It just keeps working. So, I don't want to hear this argument about this is more rugged and dependable than this. This is dependable, okay? It's a little... the plastic might be a little different. Oh, so what? It works. It works. And I can buy four of these for one of these. So, even if one breaks, and in ten years, I've never had one of these fail on me or break or anything. But if one ever did, I could get four of them for the price of one of these. And I have taken amazing pictures with this, and I guarantee you, even if I use this, those

pictures would not be any different, and they wouldn't be better. Okay, so you've got the most expensive thing in the world, but really, nobody cares. I like the compactness of it, how you can just aim this at somebody, and you're ready to go. It's just ready to use as is. I like that. I like a lot of things about this. Is it worth one and a half thousand dollars more than this? No, it's not. Anyway, this is just me. You don't have to listen to me. This is just my personal opinion. I know a lot of pro photo people are going to be up in arms about it. They want to believe. They want to convince themselves they spent money on something that's worthy, and it is. It's a great product, but you know, they don't want to feel like they wasted money or anything, so they're going to give you all the reasons why. I'm sure it's going to be in the comments why Profoto was better and all that, but you know, in the real world.

I have nothing to prove to people. I don't need to convince myself or anybody else about anything. I'm okay with Godox, so get whichever one you want. They're both good. It's not like one's that much better than anything else. It's just a matter of personal opinion, but taste. But I would rather, you know, take the money in. So let's get on with the big epic softbox lighting modifier video that's about to come up, because that's going to be a huge comparison of all kinds of stuff in the lighting world. I think you're really going to like it, so stay tuned for that. I'll see you in the next video. Bye-bye. [Music] Hi diggity, I'm diggity.

Godox AD600 vs Profoto B10 Plus OCF flash

MarkusPix

프로페셔널 사진 플래시 스트로브 비교

고독스 AD600/플래시포인트 600과 Profoto B10 Plus는 모두 강력한 플래시 스트로보로, 고독스는 $450, Profoto는 더 높은 가격대에 판매되고 있습니다.

고독스는 지난 10년 동안 스피커의 신뢰할 수 있는 선택이었으며, Profoto는 비슷한 파워에 더 작고 약간 더 가벼운 옵션을 제공합니다.

발표자는 장비 선택에 있어 독립성의 중요성을 강조하며 개인적인 경험을 바탕으로 한 솔직한 의견을 제시합니다.

플라스틱 리플렉터와 소프트박스는 각각 수백 달러에 달하는 등 Profoto의 제품은 매우 고가입니다.

이 브랜드의 높은 가격은 스웨덴에서 시작된 브랜드, 고품질 구조 및 성능에 기인합니다.

Profoto가 신뢰성과 내구성을 제공하는 반면, Godox AD600은 더 강력하고 색 정확도가 높으며 가격도 저렴하여 강력한 경쟁상대입니다.

소프트박스의 전구는 가장자리와 같은 높이에 위치하여 은색 안쪽 표면에 빛을 발산합니다.

Profoto의 사용자 인터페이스는 단순하고 우아하여 쉽고 재미있게 사용할 수 있습니다.

Profoto는 고독스보다 약간 덜 강력하지만, 가격이 높은 이유는 더 나은 구조와 사용자 경험 때문이죠.

프로 사진 수정기와 대안 비교하기

프로 사진 보정기는 가격이 비싸고 불편한 디자인으로 제공되는 경우가 많습니다.

보웬스 마운트 어댑터를 사용하면 모디파이어에 부착할 수 있어 표준 소프트박스와 호환할 수 있습니다.

저자는 두 조명 헤드를 비교하면서 한 제품이 더 작고 가볍기는 하지만, 품질과 구조의 차이가 높은 가격을 정당화할 만큼 크지 않다는 점을 지적합니다.

많은 사람들이 성공적인 사진 커리어를 위해서는 Profoto와 같은 하이엔드 장비를 사용하는 것이 필수적이라고 생각하지만, 강연자는 그렇지 않다고 주장합니다.

장비가 아닌 '훌륭한 작업과 창의력'이 진정으로 고객과 일자리를 얻을 수 있는 요소라고 강조합니다.

강연자는 저렴한 장비로 성공을 거뒀고, 더 저렴한 장비로 실패를 경험한 적이 없어 큰돈을 들이지 않고도 품질 높은 결과물을 얻을 수 있다는 것을 증명합니다.

조명 장비에 대한 개인적인 의견

화자는 가장 비싼 조명 장비는 추가 비용을 지불할 가치가 없다고 표현하며, 보다 저렴한 옵션의 소형화 및 사용 편의성을 선호한다고 말합니다.

전문 사진작가들이 고가의 옵션을 옹호할 수 있다는 점을 인정하지만, 두 옵션 모두 똑같이 훌륭하다고 생각합니다.

발표자는 다른 사람에게 무언가를 증명하려는 노력보다 개인적인 의견과 취향이 더 중요하다고 강조합니다.