[Music]  Going over there, Captain. I'd like to request that IBM understand we had some trouble over the

weekend down in Cuba. Uh, yes, sir. This past Friday, two Marines, a Lance Corporal Harold Dawson and a Private Louden

Downey, entered the barracks room of a PFC Williams Santiago and assaulted him. Santiago died at the base hospital

approximately an hour later. The NIS agent who took Dawson and Downey's statements maintains they were trying to prevent Santiago from naming

Dawson in a fence-line shooting incident. Dawson and Downey are both recruiting poster Marines, and Santiago was known to

be a screw-up. I was thinking it sounded an awful lot like a code red.  A week's worth of paperwork, sir. I think

Don't worry about it. I promise you, divisional sign-off. All right,

man for the job. All right, let's go. Let's get to [Music]

Dave, you seem distraught. We're supposed

to meet in your office 15 minutes ago to talk about them. I'm going to charge him with possession and

being under the influence while on duty. You plead guilty, I'll recommend 30 days in the brig with loss of rank and pay.

It was oregano, Dave. It was ten dollars' worth of oregano.

Yeah, well, your client thought it was marijuana.

Um, time-consuming to obtain an evidential ruling in advance, and after that I'm going to file against

pre-trial confinement, and you're going to spend the next three months going blind on paperwork because the

signalman's second class bought and smoked a dime bag of oregano. Be misdemeanor; 20 days in the brig. See,

misdemeanor; 15 days restricted duty. I don't know why I'm agreeing to this.

Washington is moving up in the world.  Been requested by division, requested to do what? Guantanamo Bay, Cuba. A Marine Corporal

named Dawson illegally fired rounds from his weapon over the fence line and into Cuban territory. PFC William Santiago

threatened to rat on Dawson. The Naval Investigative Service... Dawson and another member of his squad, PFC Louden Downey, go

into Santiago's room, tie him up, stuff a rag down his throat. And an hour later, Santiago's dead. Attending physician says

the rag was treated with some kind of toxin. He poisoned the rag. Not according to them. One of the people we'll be seeing down

there is the Barrack CEO, Colonel Nathan Jessup. I assume you've heard of him. Who hasn't? It that Santiago wrote in his

eight months at Gitmo—that's Guantanamo Bay—I knew that one. He wrote to the Fleet Commander, HQ Atlantic, to the

Commandant of the Marine Corps, even the Senator. He wanted to be transferred off the base. No one was listening. Are you

with me? Yeah. Finally, he wrote to the Naval Investigative Service where he offered information about Corporal Dawson's

fence-line shooting in exchange for a transfer. Am I correctly assuming these letters don't paint a flattering picture

of Marine Corps life, Guantanamo Bay? Yeah. Some further right in assuming that a protracted investigation of this incident might cause some embarrassment

for the Security Council guy, Colonel Jessup? 12 years. I'll get them to drop the conspiracy and conduct on becoming

12 years. You haven't talked to a witness or looked at a piece of paper? Yes. My job is to make sure that you do your

job. I'm special counsel for internal affairs, so my jurisdiction's pretty much in your face. I'm writing to inform you of my problems

with my unit here in Cuba and to ask for your help. Going down a rocky, unstable hill, my sergeant grabbed me and pushed me

down the hill, then I saw a black... the last thing I remember is hitting the deck. I ask you

to help me, please, sir. I just need to be transferred out of RSC. PS: In exchange for my transfer off the base, I wanted to

provide you with my information about the Eagle Fence Line shooting that occurred the night of August 2nd.

Who the [__] is PFC William T. Santiago? This kid broke the chain of command and

ratted on a member. Colonel, I think perhaps it would be better to hold this discussion in private.

It won't be necessary, Colonel. I can handle this situation, sir, the same way you handled the Curtis Bell incident.

Don't interrupt me, Lieutenant. I'm still your superior officer, and I'm yours, Matthew. I want to know what we're going to do

about this. I think Santiago should be transferred off the base immediately.

Transferring Santiago, while expeditious and certainly painless, might not be, in a manner of speaking, the American way. Santiago stays where he is.

We're going to train the lab, John. You're in charge. Santiago doesn't make a 4.6/4.6

on his next proficiency and conduct report, and I'm going to blame you. Then I'm going to kill you.

Yes, sir. We go back a while. We went to the academy together, we were commissioned together, we did our tours

in Vietnam together. But I've been promoted up through the chain with greater speed and success than you have.

Don't ever question my orders in front of another officer.

recommended to your supervisor that he assign you different...?  So why? But I don't think you're fit to handle the defense.

You don't even know me. It would literally take someone hours to discover I'm not fit to handle the

defense. Your father, Lionel Kathy, former Navy Judge Advocate and Attorney General of the United States, died in 1985. You went to

Harvard Law, then you joined the Navy, probably because that's what your father wanted you to do. But it's my feeling

that if this case is handled in the same fast-food, slick, and bizarre manner with which you seem to handle

everything else, then something's going to get missed. And I wouldn't be doing my job if I allowed Dawson and Downing to

spend any more time in prison than absolutely necessary because their attorney had predetermined the path of

least resistance. Code Red, Sarah? Code Red is a disciplinary engagement.  No, sir. Silver polished turpentine,

antifreeze... No, sir. We were just going to shave his head, sir, when all of a sudden we saw blood

dripping down his mouth, and we pulled the tape off, and there was blood all down his face, sir.

That's when Lance Corporal Dawson called the ambulance. Did anyone see you call the ambulance? They plead guilty; we dropped the

conspiracy and the conduct.  Coming 20 years, their home and happened. I want 12. Can't do it, Greg. Was he tested for poison?

The autopsy lab reports; they all say the same thing. Maybe... maybe not. Chief of Internal Medicine at the Guantanamo Bay

Naval Hospital says he's sure. What do you know about Code Reds? I'm gonna give you the 12 years

before you go get yourself into trouble. Tomorrow, I think you should know the platoon commander, Lieutenant Jonathan

Kendrick, held a meeting with the men and specifically told them not to touch Santiago. [Music]

I do have to ask you a couple of questions about the September 6th shooting. In the morning, at six, you were contacted by

an NIS agent who said that Santiago tipped him off to an illegal fence-line shooting. Yes, Santiago is going to reveal

the person's name in exchange for a transfer. Yes, Santiago was set to be transferred on the first available flight to the States.

Oh, 6:00 the next morning—five hours too late, as it turned out. I was just wondering if you've ever

heard the term 'Code Red'. I've heard the term. She has no point; she often has no points, or it's part of her

charm. We're out of here. Thank you. My point is that I think Code Reds still go on down here.

She outranks you, Daddy. You're the luckiest man in the world. There is nothing on this Earth sexier,

believe me, gentlemen, than a woman that you have to salute in the morning. I don't answer to my question, sir. Take

caution in your tone, Commander. I'm a fair guy, but this [ __ ] heat is making me absolutely

crazy. Colonel, I just need a copy of Santiago's transfer orders. What's that? Santiago's transfer? You guys have

paperwork on that kind of thing? I...I just need it for the file. You have to ask me

nicely. I beg your pardon. You have to ask me nicely. You gotta ask me nicely, Colonel. Jessup, it's not too much trouble.

I'd like a copy of the transfer order, sir. No problem, sir. Don't say 'sir' like I just asked you

if you clean the latrine. Yes, sir. Okay. Yes, sir. Who did it again? There's a platoon meeting on September

6th in the afternoon. Kendrick says that he gave strict instructions that nothing was to happen.

to Santiago, and that's correct. But then he dismissed the platoon, and we all went to our rooms. And what happened

then Lieutenant Kendrick came to our room, man, when—about five minutes after the meeting broke, sir—about 1620. And what happened

then Lieutenant Kendrick ordered us to give Santiago a code red. Kendrick specifically told those men not

to touch Santiago. That's right. And then he went into Dawson's room and specifically told him to give him a code

red. That's not what Kendrick—Kendrick's alive. Division will give me a lot of room on

this one. The spare chest and the core. Any embarrassment, I'll knock it all down to involuntary manslaughter. Two years

are home in six months. No deal. We're going to court. Johnny knows that if we do go to court, I'm gonna have to go all

the way. They're going to be charged with a whole truckload: murder, conspiracy, conduct unbecoming. See, Danny is an

awfully talented lawyer, and he's not about to see his clients go to jail for life when he knows they can

Do what? We did nothing wrong, sir. We did our job, and if that has consequences and

I'll accept them. We joined the Marines because we wanted to live our lives by a certain code. If a

court decides that what we did was wrong, then I'll accept whatever punishment they give. But I believe I was right, sir.

I believe I did my job, and I will not dishonor myself, my unit, or the Corps, so I

can go home in six months. Are you so afraid to be a lawyer where Daddy's expectations are really that high? Oh,

please spare me the psychobabble, Father. [ __ ] Another lawyer won't be good enough. They need you. You know how to win.

You know they have a case, and you know how to win. If you walk away from this now, you've sealed their fate.

Their fate was sealed the moment Santiago died. You know nothing about the law. You're a used car salesman, Daniel. You're an

ambulance chaser with a rank. You're nothing. Good night. You want to take this to court? You're going to force me

to file like nine kinds of discovery motions, and you're going to spend the better part of a year going blind on

천재 협상가가 승소 확률 0.1% 재판에서 각잡고 변호하면 벌어지는 일 [영화리뷰/결말포함]

안녕하세요^^
영화 리뷰 채널 디토이야기 입니다.

디토이야기

쿠바에서 발생한 해병대원 사망 사건과 초기 조사

해병대원 Dawson과 Downey가 Santiago를 폭행하여 사망에 이르게 함.

NIS 요원은 Dawson과 Downey가 Santiago가 Dawson을 폭로하는 것을 막으려 했다고 진술.

Dawson과 Downey는 우수한 해병대원이었고, Santiago는 문제 해결 능력이 부족했음.

변호사는 사건에 더 많은 것이 개입되어 있을 것이라고 의심.

상관은 사건에 대해 걱정하지 말라고 함.

변호사는 피고에게 마약 소지 및 근무 중 약물 복용 혐의를 적용할 예정임.

유죄를 인정하면 징역 30일과 계급 및 급여 감봉을 권고할 것임.

마약이 아니고 오레가노였음에도 불구하고 피고는 마리화나로 오인함.

변호사는 증거 규칙을 얻는 데 시간이 걸리고, 재판 전 구금에 반대할 예정임.

변호사는 사건을 경범죄로 처리하여 징역 20일 또는 제한 근무 15일로 줄이려고 함.

Dawson이 쿠바 영토로 총기를 발사한 사건.

Santiago가 Dawson을 폭로하려 했고, 그 결과 Dawson과 Downey가 Santiago를 폭행함.

Santiago는 독극물이 묻은 천으로 인해 사망함.

Santiago가 여러 기관에 전출을 요청했으나 무시당함.

Santiago의 편지와 사건의 진상규명 시도

Santiago는 자신이 폭행당했다는 내용의 편지를 씀.

Santiago는 상관에게 도움을 요청하고 전출을 원함.

Santiago는 전출과 함께 Dawson의 총기 사건에 대한 정보를 제공하려 함.

Jessup 대령은 Santiago의 행동에 대해 비판적임.

변호사는 사건을 비밀리에 처리하려고 함.

변호사와 Jessup 대령 간의 갈등과 재판 전략

변호사와 Jessup 대령은 과거에 함께 근무했던 사이임.

Jessup 대령은 변호사의 능력에 의문을 제기함.

변호사의 아버지가 전직 해군 법무관이었음을 언급하며 변호사의 자세를 비판함.

Jessup 대령은 변호사가 사건을 너무 쉽게 처리하려 한다고 비판함.

변호사는 피고들이 불필요하게 오랫동안 감옥에 있지 않도록 하겠다고 다짐함.

Santiago가 NIS 요원에게 정보를 제공하려 했다는 증언.

'Code Red' 용어에 대한 질문과 답변.

변호사가 Jessup 대령에게 Santiago의 전출 명령서 사본을 요청함.

Kendrick 중위가 Santiago를 건드리지 말라는 지시를 내렸다는 증언.

Kendrick 중위가 Code Red를 지시했다는 증언.

NIS 요원이 Santiago의 편지를 받았다는 증언.