하마스, 이스라엘, 팔레스타인 분쟁에 대한 열띤 논쟁

### 이스라엘-팔레스타인 분쟁에 대한 열띤 옥스퍼드 연합 토론회
* 🗣 혼란스러운 옥스퍼드 유니온 토론이 벌어졌고, 질서 유지와 중단을 거듭 요구했습니다.
* 🗣 팔레스타인인이 아닌 아랍인이라고 밝힌 이 연사는 가자지구에서 이스라엘의 행동을 옹호하며 민간인 사상자를 극대화한 하마스를 비판했습니다.
* 🗣 그는 하마스가 정치적 이득을 위해 인간 방패를 사용하고 어린이를 희생시킨 반면 이스라엘은 민간인 사상자를 최소화했다고 주장했습니다.
* 🗣 ️ 하마스의 행동과 민간인 사상자를 줄이기 위한 이스라엘의 노력에 대한 연사의 주장은 강력한 반대에 부딪혔습니다.
* 🗣 하마스의 공격을 신고하겠다고 답한 참석자의 비율이 낮아 연사에 대한 무관심이나 두려움에 대한 비난이 이어졌습니다.
* 🗣 ️ 화자의 태도와 전달 방식에 의문을 제기하며 '트롤' 또는 위장 근무하는 '미친 요원'이라는 의혹이 제기되었습니다.
* 🗣 이스라엘의 주장을 그대로 반영한 그의 주장은 그의 진정한 정체성과 동기에 대한 의심을 불러일으켰습니다.
* 🗣 이 동영상은 화자가 선동적인 수사를 사용하여 온라인 참여를 유도하는 이스라엘 요원이거나 도발자일 수 있다는 추측으로 끝을 맺습니다.

하마스의 행동은 정치적 이득을 위해 민간인 사상자를 극대화했습니다.

A point of order has been raised. I have to hear the point of order.

Could I hear the point of order from the member? Order! Sit down! Order! It is not for you to tell a member to sit down. A point of

order is directed to the Chair. Sit down! Order! Order! Order! Could I hear the point of order from the member of Senate?

I am not going to apologize for reporting Hamas and for reporting terrorists, and know that we will fight anyone who

takes the side of terrorists. Hamas is a terrorist organization in the UK, in the United States, in the European Union, and

it's not up to you to [Applause] decide. Sit down now! There come the

Palestinians, the most pathetic people on planet [Applause] Earth who want... Who is out of order? Sit down! The Speaker

is out of order. Delegitimize... If the Speaker... Order! Who want to... When the Chair... When the Chair is making a ruling, the Speaker

must remain seated. If the Speaker repeats this again, I will have to ask them to leave. This... This House has

been hijacked. Muslims... Could I hear the point of order? Could I hear the point of order? Order! Could I hear the

point of order, please? Have the... The point of order is behind you. What? Order! Could... Could I hear the point of order from the

member? Could I hear the point of order? Order! Could I hear the point of order, please? State your point of order.

He made absolutely no reference to anyone in this chamber. He passed an opinion on his own people. Will he please be allowed to

continue to debate, given how important his voice is? Order! Order! Order! I have made my ruling very

clear. What is your ruling? I did not insult anyone in the room. You've never been to Gaza. You don't

Know what you're talking about, so sit down. After the war... after the war, what was the date? Where did you...

go after the war? After October 7th? Can the speaker desist from addressing other members? The most authentic nation in the

Middle East, the only Jewish state on the planet, and he wants... he wants the children of Gaza to do the job on his

behalf, on his... on behalf of his political ambitions. And I tell him, why don't you

carry a rifle and fight the apartheid state? Why are the children of Gaza supposed to fight on your behalf and on behalf of

your righteousness? You are not the savior! This is a very severe state of mental illness; that you think that you are the

savior of God's children, because you are not the savior. And Israel did everything within their ability to minimize civilian

casualties in Gaza, while... while Hamas... while Hamas did everything in their ability to maximize civilian casualties. The speaker will be...

Hamas did everything within their ability to maximize civilian casualties for political and financial gain, for global sympathy, and they succeeded in fooling

so many people. But this is not going to change the reality on the ground. Raise your hands if you had

information about the Hamas attack on October 7th. Would you report it to the authorities? If you do, raise your

hand. Sit down. Less than 5% in this room raised their hands that they would report a massive terrorist attack that targeted

civilians. Could it be that no one just wanted to answer you because you look like a creep? You look like this guy...

looks creepy, man. Like, first of all, he seems very violent. He seems a little crazy, honestly. That's what it is; he

seems a little crazy with all his body language and his eyes. Like, bro, why are you so pissed off? Criminally, that

Includes Arabs, Muslims, Jews. So I've seen this guy's video once on Piers Morgan, I think. He's on Piers Morgan with Chen...

And that's why he's here. I have no idea who he really is. It seems like he's

saying he's an Arab, but he's not Palestinian. I don't, I don't really get

that, and I wouldn't be surprised if he's kind of like a mad agent, um, because what many people don't realize is that the

people that are, um, Jewish and Palestinian in Israel, they look pretty much the same. You can't really tell the

difference between them; they both look Middle Eastern. And this guy is saying a lot of the same talking points as Israel

is; like, he's saying the same verbatim talking points as Israel. And there have been many stories of, uh, mad agents going

undercover and infiltrating Muslim communities and whatnot. So I would not be surprised if he's an agent. Christians, peaceful

farming communities on October 7, ethnically cleansing 20 Jewish communities because of their ethnicity

and because of their religion. And I was born as an Arab. Is it because of their ethnicity and religion, or is it because

they're doing it to the Palestinians? I don't know. I was not born as a Palestinian, like millions of Arab

children. And the Palestinians have been pushing the Palestinian violent indoctrination based on a false narrative of apartheid, colonialism, genocide,

occupation, while Palestine never existed as a sovereign country. It never...

stop interrupting me and listen now. It almost feels like he has a

fake accent here because... stop interrupting me. Like, he has grammar, but then he has very good vocabulary. He is

able to express himself very well in English, uh, with all the different talking points, and he knows all the key

Words, so I don't know, man. It's just this guy seems a little suspicious. I'm not

sure what his background is or what he is, but definitely a little suspicious. Their strategy, and this is what we

need to discuss here on the floor tonight, is the use of human shields and the evil practice of sacrificing

children for political and financial gain. This is the mastery. See, look at the propaganda: sacrificing children, when in reality,

who's the one, which side is killing children by shooting them in the head? So is it really a sacrifice? I mean,

Israel does not have to shoot children in the head. The Palestinians are doing this. They want the children,

the Arab children, to continue carrying the burden of their sick indoctrination for

eternity. And the joke on the Palestinians is that they actually claim to be indigenous to the land, fighting

against colonialism while they choose a colonial entity as their national identity. How pathetic is that? I see on one side he

has a very thick accent and is making silly grammar mistakes, but then on the other hand, he uses such complicated ideologies it's

almost like he read a script and memorized it. I'm not sure if anyone else notices this or if it's just me. I find it

really unbelievable that the Palestinians continue spreading this lie, and millions of people around the world believe

them. If you know, they talk about genocide. Israel sent leaflets, millions of text messages, they made phone calls; they

gave safe passage to people to evacuate the war zone, while Hamas embedded itself in schools. Wow, they sent leaflets, huh?

Papers, warnings. Wow, 'we're going to destroy your homes, move.' So I guess we do the...if if Russia does that to Ukraine,

It's okay, then, huh? Hospitals... they did not leave any secret zone for the civilians to evacuate to safety, then.

They blocked the entire area because Hamas does not care for the Arab children; Hamas does not care for the

Jewish children. Arabs and Jews. Arabs and Jews. Yes, your insults think they can challenge or defy my truth. Arabs and Jews can get

along. I have faith in that. Arabs, we are an ethnic group, not...

Come on, this guy's a troll. I wish people didn't react so emotionally to him. He's a troll; he's just trying to piss people

off, and people are getting pissed off, and that's what's giving him virality and views. We were way before Islam came to

the region. We were way before the Palestinians came to the region. And, by the way, the Palestinian history started

Is he not Palestinian, though? If he's an Arab born in that region...

I'm pretty sure he identifies as a Palestinian. No. Why is he saying he's not a Palestinian? Because it goes against the Israeli agenda,

CIA, and the Palestinian flag. This is their heritage. We will continue way after the Palestinian...

fugs who came to hijack our society with their sick indoctrination and victim narrative. Israel will be our strategic

friend, and we will get along: Kurds, Jews, Arabs, Druze, and the rest of the region. And I hope that the Palestinians

will know their place in history; nothing but a false identity. This is who they are, and this is how they are going to...

This is a clever game that the guy is playing. First of all, he's obviously a troll. He's saying things and being very

provocative just to piss people off. And if people fall for that... come on, man, you've got to be better than that. That's

really propaganda now. The other thing is this is a clever type of propaganda where they're acting like someone from

within, so they're able to criticize and it means more, right? So if like someone criticizes you uh and what you're doing

wrong, like it doesn't mean anything, but when when it's from your own people, it's a lot more meaningful and impactful, and

that's what they're trying to... In my opinion, this guy's like a Mossad agent or something. I don't think he's actually

Palestinian. Uh, he could just be Israeli and acting as a Palestinian, but it's just... it's insane. I don't really know

much about this guy and it's going viral right now. Hope you enjoyed this video. I'll see you in the next one. Make sure

you like this video and subscribe to my channel for more content. See you.

Crazy Violent Zionist Gets Booed Off Stage LIVE on BANNED Oxford Union Debate!!

Inaam Khan

토론 중 방해 및 질서 유지 요령

여러 건의 주문이 제기되어 토론의 흐름을 방해합니다.

화자는 반복적으로 질서를 요구하며 통제력을 유지하기 위해 고군분투합니다.

발표자가 순서대로 연설을 하려고 하지만 계속 방해를 받습니다.

하마스 보도와 테러리스트 규탄에 대한 연설자의 변호

연사가 하마스를 테러 조직으로 신고한 것에 대해 사과를 거부합니다.

연사는 하마스가 국제적으로 테러 조직이라고 주장합니다.

연사가 팔레스타인 사람들을 비판하여 더 많은 방해가 발생하고 질서를 요구합니다.

의장이 하원이 탈취당했다고 말합니다.

발표자는 주문 요점을 명확하게 진술하도록 반복해서 요청합니다.

연사는 이스라엘을 중동에서 가장 정통적인 국가라고 부릅니다.

연사가 가잔 어린이들이 이스라엘의 정치적 야망을 위해 싸워야 하는 이유에 대해 질문합니다.

청중의 반응과 발표자의 신뢰성에 대한 질문

청중은 발표자에 대해 회의적이고 부정적인 의견을 표명합니다.

화자의 태도가 폭력적이고 미친 사람으로 묘사됩니다.

발표자의 신원 및 잠재적 소속에 대한 논의가 이루어집니다.

연사의 외모와 화두를 이스라엘인의 외모와 비교합니다.

화자가 위장 요원일 수 있다는 추측이 제기됩니다.

인간 방패를 사용하고 어린이를 희생시키는 화자의 전략에 대해 논의합니다.

연사는 이스라엘이 아닌 팔레스타인이 어린이 살해의 책임이 있다고 주장합니다.

연사는 팔레스타인의 희생자 서사와 식민주의에 대해 비판합니다.

연사는 팔레스타인 사람들이 식민지 정체성을 채택하면서 원주민 지위를 주장하는 아이러니를 지적합니다.

연사는 팔레스타인의 대량 학살 이야기를 일축하고 민간인 사상자를 최소화하려는 이스라엘의 노력을 강조합니다.

마무리 발언 및 발표자의 행동에 대한 평가

화자는 감정적인 반응을 유발하기 위해 트롤로 묘사됩니다.

연사는 이 지역에서 이슬람과 팔레스타인보다 먼저 유대인이 역사적으로 존재했음을 주장합니다.

연사는 팔레스타인을 제외한 이스라엘과 이 지역의 다양한 그룹 간의 미래 관계에 대한 희망을 표명합니다.

화자의 행동은 모사드 요원을 고용했을 가능성이 있는 교묘한 선전 전략으로 묘사됩니다.

동영상은 좋아요, 구독, 더 많은 콘텐츠 보기를 요청하는 것으로 마무리됩니다.