So, AI was in my opinion the best music generator until a few days ago when its competition showed up, Audio. So today I want to compare Sunno versus Audio to see which is the best music generator and I'm going to be comparing the two bar for bar, pound for pound.

[Music] intended is the best generator. First, we're going to be starting with the pricing, then we want to talk about the features and the user experience, and then I want to show you guys a bunch of prompts so you guys can decide which one is best because I think

there are some pros and cons to both. But with that being said, let's get started with the most important pricing. First of all, they both have free plans, and you can generate songs on both for free. And Audio doesn't actually yet have a paid plan, it's entirely free for now because

it's still in beta, so it's 100% free. There's no way you could actually give them money if you wanted to, but that's likely to change in the near future of course as soon as it's out of beta. But right now with Audio, you can generate up

to 1,200 songs a month. Every time you generate a prompt, it does two songs, so you get 600 generations a month. And the fact that you can already get so much for free again will probably also change once they have a paid plan, I'm sure

these limits will be reduced. Now, looking at Sunno's free plan, you get 50 credits that renew daily and it costs five credits per song, so you do get 10 songs a day. But again, every prompt generates two songs just like with Audio, so technically

you get five generations a day if you add this all up it adds to about 150 generations a month for 300 songs but to get the maximum amount of songs a month with Suno you'd have to use your five generations every day which you most

likely won't do the reason I started paying for Suno you know before Audio actually came out is because I wanted to do 20 songs and 20 generations at a time I didn't want to have to wait and spread it across 4 days because you rarely get

the exact song you want or that you need with the first generation and speaking of paid plan I'm actually on the $10 a month Pro Plan and I'm paying monthly and the reason is is because I get 500 songs a month which would equal to about

250 generations and I can also then use this music commercially which means I can use it in my videos and then monetize them and you also get priority generation queue but I haven't really noticed too much of a difference and then the final thing is you can run up to 10

jobs at once compared to just doing two but I rarely generate multiple songs at the same time I think the max I've done maybe is two just because I like to hear what I got from the first prompt before giving it another one and Suno those

generations have never taken more than 30 seconds max I think whereas Audio is actually a lot slower but I'll get to that in a minute but if we had to compare Audio to Suno on just the free plans in my opinion Audio wins because

you can get 450 songs more a month than Suno's free plan and you've got way more flexibility because you can generate a bunch at a time instead of being limited to five generations a day but again, likely to change. However, when it comes to the paid plan, Suno wins

because Audio doesn't yet have one and the pay plan with Suno gives you commercial rights which Audio you don't actually have yet. So I'll be curious to know what Audio's paid plans look like. And now when you sign up to the tools

they're both very similar. This is Suno, you've got the menu bar on the top left, and then if we take a look at Audio, we've also got the menus here on the top left. The biggest difference is on Audio you have the generation bar at the top

at all times compared to Suno, you have to be on the create page. But then you've also got home, library, and explore, and here you've also got discover and then like songs, and then down here you've got your playlists because on both you can

create your own playlists. If you want to see your profile on Suno, it's down in the bottom left, and you've got some other tabs you can also see your credit consumption. And then on Audio, all of this information is actually on the top right, and you've also got a bunch of

documentation etc. right here. But you're notice if I click on pricing, as you can see, it's currently in beta so it's all free now. One thing I do like about both tools is that all generations are private by default. So for an example, as

you can see here they are all private if I did want to make one public I can just click toggle and then it becomes public but I can just quickly switch that off right now and as you can see it's now link only so I can share it and I can

also delete them I can move it to trash and then I have to go and empty my trash on audio it's a pretty similar experience if I wanted to publish one I just click publish and then if I want to unpublish it I just click unpublish but

enough about the actual user interface let's compare some of the results and every time I'm going to put about a 5 to 10 second snippet of the song and we're going to compare them both side by side so now the first generation I did was

this one right here on both the prompt I used was realm of melodic Tranquility WP and for this one I was on automatic mode so essentially I just put in the prompt and click create and on audio same thing here I just click auto-generated put in

the prompt and click create so these are the automatic settings side by side and now if we take a listen here through Melodies mys I don't think that sounds amazing wondering through the CLS I my sounds okay but if we go to audio give

these two a listen you D now so I don't know [Music] realm of calm where my thoughts compose like whispers see here they sound much better on audio in my opinion I think it matches the prompt a lot better and the lyrics sound better so for the second

one I decided to do a prompt that was a little bit more complex and from Sunno we got the song called "Speeding Ducks" and the prompt here was "New Wave rock song about driving fast down the highway with a fleet of ducks flying just above you while feeling the breeze in your

hair" and by the way I do want to mention that I really like the fact that Sunno directly gives you the prompts on the side. You can get this from Udio but you actually have to click on the song just like this. But let's see what it sounds

like. [Music] Sunno feeling production. [Music] Good generations, but they don't sound amazing. Now if we go to Udio and we listen to "Ducks and Drive" which I think is a better name than "Speeding [Music] Ducks"

and "Ducks" a line, a fleet and flight accelerating. Now the wind rushes all around. This to me sounds a little bit more New Wave Rock and it also sounds clearer. I think the lyrics are better in this one as well. But remember I did say that Sunno wins in some areas compared

to Udio. So if we go back to Sunno because I think Udio is winning quite a lot right now, here is the first song where Sunno takes the cake. So for this one, what I decided to do if I just click open is I actually used custom mode this

time, and for the lyrics I entered "Eat, Sleep, Repeat" which will sound familiar for obvious reasons, and then for the style I actually input "Citron Techno". And now give these to a [Music] listen. "Eat, Sleep, Repeat." So use the lyrics there and the next [Music]

One so used the lyrics there as well, and I actually think these sound really good. But now if we go to udio again, I did the same things. I put in pitron techno obviously on custom mode, and then we put in Eat Sleep Rave Repeat, and what actually

happened is we got a moderation error. And I'm guessing it's because udio picked up the Eat Sleep Rave Repeat as already very famous lyrics or it's, I think, the name of the actual song as well. And so it couldn't generate it, but what I ended

up doing is if I click on here, is I just changed it to beat Leap Day repeat, so very different. And so these two songs are supposed to be pitron techno now. Let's take a listen compared to the Sunno ones. I don't think either of these are

anywhere near as good as the pitron techno songs we got from Sunno, and it doesn't also use the custom lyrics that I input. Or be it the lyrics were weird, Sunno still incorporated them into the tracks. Here they don't, in my opinion, fit

the prompt. And so now that we've done lyric ones, what I wanted to do is test out the instrumental features. So here for the instrumental feature, I decided to go pretty simple. And so here we've got back to the classics, the simple prompt was rhythmic old school hip-hop

and obviously no lyrics because it's an instrumental, but let's take a listen. Good, but super simple, nothing [Music] crazy. Good again, super simple, quite repetitive, nothing crazy. But if we go back to udio now, let's take a listen to

these two right here [Music] so here I think these instrumentals are better and the reason being is because they're not as repetitive they've got more of a feel to old school hip-hop beats and they are a lot more dynamic basically so like I said they're a lot

less repetitive you've got different elements that come in and come out and they're not just repeating the same four bars so here for the instrumentals I think that audio wins whereas going back to the techno and electronic music I think sunos is a lot better and now the

last thing I wanted to try was something quite experimental because I've seen some people on Reddit with experimental prompting and so here all I decided to do was prompt telephone ringing and let's go to sunno first and see what this sounds like [Applause]

okay so this was obviously set on instrumental mode they kind of sounded like one of those really bad ringtones you get on a Samsung phone but if we go to udio take a listen to [Music] this this doesn't sound like a telephone

ringing at all and then if we go to this one again it sounds like some ambient soundscape even though it's supposed to just be a telephone ringing and so what I decided to do is on udio there's actually this feature which is called

manual mode because basically udio actually rewrites the prompts for you to get better outputs so I decided to toggle this on so the audio doesn't rewrite the prompts for me okay and then I put in the same thing so telephone ringing and this is what we got

[Music] doesn't sound like a telephone ringing at all. Not quite sure where these generations are coming from, but manual mode seems to have a super big input on the results. And I'm guessing it almost bypasses any of these, so the results

What is the best AI music generator? First of all, I'd love to hear what you think, but I think that Sounnd is good for electronic music. It comes up with some good lyrics when you're prompting to get a song, but the vocals in the songs don't

quite sound as good, and these songs don't sound super high quality. However, I feel like they match the prompts that I give it quite well. But taking a look at Audio, things sound super crisp, super clear, super high quality. Honestly, it's pretty insane, but I'm guessing there's a

lot of rewriting of the actual prompts to get it to sound good, and because of that, I often feel like the prompts that I give it don't match the kind of song that I'm trying to go for. But it wins in terms of quality. But with that being said,

I would love to know what do you guys think? What do you think of the generations in this video? Have you tried them? And what do you think of the results that you guys have been getting? And tell me between Sounnd and Audio, which one do you think is the best AI music

generator? You found this video helpful, you enjoyed it, subscribe, hit the like button, peace.

Best AI Music Generator in 2024 - SUNO vs UDIO

Alec Wilcock

Suno와 오디오 AI 음악 생성기 비교: 가격 및 기능

둘 다 무료 요금제를 제공하며, 오디오는 완전히 무료(베타)입니다.

오디오: 월 최대 1200곡(600세대).

수노: 일일 50크레딧, 곡당 5크레딧(하루 10곡, 월 최대 150세대).

Suno Pro 요금제(월 $10): 월 500곡, 상업적 권한, 우선 생성.

무료 요금제에서는 오디오가, 유료 요금제(상업적 권리)에서는 수노가 승리합니다.

사용자 인터페이스 및 경험 비교

유사한 메뉴 레이아웃(왼쪽 상단).

오디오에는 영구 생성 표시줄이 있으며, 수노의 생성 표시줄은 생성 페이지에 있습니다.

프로필 정보 위치가 다릅니다(Suno에서는 왼쪽 하단, 오디오에서는 오른쪽 상단).

둘 다 기본적으로 비공개 세대가 있습니다.

오디오와 수노 세대 비교: 다양한 프롬프트

프롬프트: "멜로디의 평온함의 영역"; 오디오는 더 나은 결과를 만들어 냈습니다.

프롬프트: "빠르게 운전하는 것에 관한 뉴웨이브 록 노래..." 오디오가 더 나은 결과를 가져왔습니다.

가사("먹고, 자고, 반복") 및 스타일("유자 테크노")이 포함된 사용자 지정 모드에서 Suno는 더 나은 결과를 만들어 냈습니다.

악기 프롬프트("리드미컬한 올드스쿨 힙합"); 오디오를 사용하면 더 나은 결과를 얻을 수 있습니다.

실험적 프롬프트("전화 벨소리"); Suno의 결과는 프롬프트에 더 가깝습니다.

결론: 각 발전기에 대한 전반적인 평가

Suno: 전자 음악, 괜찮은 가사에는 좋지만 오디오 품질이 떨어집니다.

오디오: 고품질 오디오이지만 프롬프트가 항상 결과와 일치하지 않을 수 있습니다.