Analytic Idealism: Understanding Death and Meaning of Life

Analytic idealism reveals that life’s suffering holds intrinsic meaning, transforming our fear of death into a profound understanding of existence.

### The Dual Nature of Death: Fear and Meaning in Analytic Idealism
* 🌌 The concept of death raises **profound questions about existence** and the **first-person perspective of dying**, particularly in the context of **analytic idealism**.
* 😨 Historically, materialism has alleviated the fear of what happens after death, suggesting that there is "**no hell**" or heaven, effectively removing the **existential dread** surrounding death.
* 🧠 However, analytic idealism posits that our **core subjectivity**, which remains constant, experiences life and death as events within it, indicating that there is **something that continues to exist after death**.
* 💤 The good news is that the process of dying may resemble **waking from a dream**, where the insights and experiences accumulated throughout life are **not lost but integrated into a broader cognitive context**.
* 🌱 Under analytic idealism, the meaning of life is tied to **experience and learning**, suggesting that our **suffering and insights** contribute to a **larger understanding** within the fabric of nature.
* 🧩 This perspective allows individuals to **confront the fear of death** while also recognizing the **intrinsic meaning of their existence**, as metacognition provides a unique lens through which to **explore life's deeper questions**.
* 💡 Ultimately, while fear of death persists, it coexists with a **profound sense of meaning**, enabling individuals to **embrace life fully**, despite its inherent uncertainties.
* 🌍 The journey of existence is thus framed as a **rich tapestry of experiences** that contribute to the **greater consciousness of the universe**, inviting us to **reflect on our unique role within it**.

So the Big Bang, the very beginning in the past. What about the future? What about our death, the most certain event in life which is coming for all of us? What does analytic idealism tell us about death, particularly the first-person perspective of death? What do we

experience as we die? Now, there is good and bad news. I'll start with the bad news. One of the main social psychological reasons why materialism has taken such a fundamental hold in our culture since the late 19th century is because it did away with the

greatest fear of humankind throughout almost the entirety of our history, which was the fear of what we will experience after we die. In Christian language, are we going to go to hell? This singular fear, the biggest fear in human history, has been used by government and

power structures worldwide to, to control civilizations, to control societies. It's the single most dominant fear in the history of humankind, and materialism did away with it because you will not experience anything after you die. There is no hell, there is no Heaven either. But there is no hell, there

is no reason to be anxious about that great, uh, scary unknown because there will be no subjects there. Someone said once, 'Where death is, I am not. Where I am, death is not.' And that's a materialist axiom or a materialist theorem, if you will.

Unfortunately, under analytical idealism, your course objectivity remains as you go through the process of death and even after, because your course objectivity is the core's objectivity of nature. It's what exists. Where is it going to go? Life and death happen to it within it.

um life and death are events in core subjectivity, not at the beginning and end of course objectivity. So the core subjectivity in you, that thing that remains when you are in an ideal sensory deprivation chamber completely amnesic, that thing that remains remains through the

re-association process that we call that. So there will be someone there, there will be something there to experience, and the greatest fear of humankind is that that's the bad news. Now the good news, the good news is we go through a reassociative process

every single day when we are asleep and dreaming. We are dissociated internally, we identify with our Dream Avatar, not with the cars and buildings and streets and trees and other people in our dream. We think those things are other than us because we are

the Dream Avatar. When we wake up from a dream we realize that actually it was us doing the whole thing. We were doing everything, not only the Dream Avatar, we were the whole thing. And the moment we wake up our Dream Avatar, this toast, is dead, he's gone.

But nobody goes around mourning the death of their Dream Avatar every morning because you realized that you were it, but it was not you. In other words, you were the superset, your Dream Avatar was something you were doing, not what you are. Um, and the same applies hierarchically

speaking, we can transpose that one level up in the hierarchy of Nature and say it's the same thing regarding life and death. We are Alters or dissociated dream avatars, and I think we don't have any reason to think that when we die our reaction will be any different than

It is when we wake up in the morning and our dream avatar is dead. In other words, I don't think we will go around mourning the death of our individual selves, um, in this great play of life beyond that. I don't know, only the gods know, and they haven't come

back to tell me. So it's a great mystery, and we have to live with it, and it's scary. But there is one thing that we got back together with the great fear, and that is meaning. Because although materialism got rid of the greatest fear of humankind, it also

got rid of the meaning of life. Because if subjectivity is an epiphenomenon of material arrangements, um, and eventually all of your thoughts, all of your emotions, all of your insights, all of your wisdom that you've accumulated at great cost with great

suffering through life, eventually they will all be gone, and they will mean exactly nothing. That's materialism. So we get rid of the fear of death, but we get rid of meaning. Under analytic idealism, on the other hand, the contents of your dissociative

process, all the insights, all the maturity you've acquired at the cost of unspeakable suffering through life, because suffering is an intrinsic element of life, all of those gains are not lost. They are released in a broader cognitive context. They are made available to the mind of

nature, to mind at large. And ultimately all of your suffering is not for nothing. There is a meaning to that. There is something, not something, there is all of it. It remains present in the fabric of nature, and not only that, it remains much more broadly accessible

Uh, in the fabric of nature, you can see this metaphorically as remembering your dreams. When you wake up, you are no longer your dream avatar, but the mental contents of your dream avatar survive in you. You remember the dream. You remember thinking that you were your dream avatar.

And dreams are incredibly informative. You can learn so much about yourself. You can get so much insight about who you really are, what you really fear, what your hopes and dreams are, what your anxieties are, what your traumas are, and how to reintegrate them. You can learn

all that from your dreams, even or particularly after you wake up. As a matter of fact, you can't do that during the dream, but after you wake up, you can reintegrate the memories of a lifetime of dreams and be a more mature, a wiser, better, more

integrated, more individuated person. Could that be happening at the level of the Universe? I would submit to you that this is a very reasonable, coherent hypothesis, and it flows very naturally from the premises of analytic idealism. So fear is back, but meaning is also back.

That's the good news. So what is the meaning of life ultimately? It's experience, and it's what you learn from your experience. Because we are metacognitive, we are able to ask the deeper questions. A non-metacognitive animal just glides

through life, always in the moment, always reacting to the environment, but not asking the big questions like, "What is going on?" Which is the ultimate, the deepest question is, "What is going on?" Which sounds so basic, but it's so incredibly deep, so so profound. Or, "What is the self?" What

Am I, what am I doing here? What is this for? What is the meaning of this dance? What a strange condition life is, to maintain an organism outside of thermodynamic equilibrium for a few decades. It's incredibly weird. What is this? What's going on? Is there a reason?

Is there, is there a telos that goes to all of this? And what's the relationship between me and the rest of nature? These are the big questions, and we ask the big questions as metacognitive individuals. And this metacognition, we have every reason to believe, exists only in life.

Only through life does the universe metacognize, because metacognition is something that arose from the evolution of life in a planetary ecosystem. It's a higher levelment of function that was engineered by the evolution of life. Without it, no matter cognition, without

life, no matter cognition. So this puts us in a unique position in the dance of existence. Only through our eyes can the mind of nature take account of itself in an explicit manner, and, and ask the larger, the bigger questions, and get the answers. When we are no

longer dissociated, um, it may sound cruel to say what I'm about to say, so I have to be very careful. The intuition of the world's cultures and civilizations almost always has a seed of truth, even when it's distorted into morally

despicable acts. I'll mention one morally despicable act, animal sacrifice or even human sacrifice, both of which have been practiced by cultures the world over through most of history. Do I think that's okay now? I don't think that's okay. We are going to die.

eventually anyway there is absolutely no need to speed up the process and to speed up the process it's actually to spit in the face of nature it's nature that should decide when it's time um not us not the ego to take the reins

from nature and and cut a life short having said that there is a seed of truth to the intuition death is the end of the dissociation so when you die whatever insights you've accumulated about the bigger questions are released into a broader cognitive context linked to the very fabric of

nature so there is a sense in which sacrifice is an offering to the divinity um which is no endorsement of sacrifice but I'm just trying to highlight that people's intuitions don't come out of nothing they are not great twitters they

are not arbitrary usually there is a foundation a core of truth in that intuition another example of the same intuition is how we depict the figure of the reaper of death which is usually a black cloaked creature with a hood carrying guess what

a harvesting instrument a harvesting instrument you plant the seed of life and you harvest it and what is harvest Harvest is when you bank the gains and you use it for the benefit of the tribe there are cores of truth to all this this these things don't pop out

arbitrarily for no reason in in the world's cultures and they do hint at the meaning of life they do hint at why we are here and the moral responsibility we carry as as far as we know the only truly metacognizant eyes

of nature, it is a tremendous responsibility to carry, particularly given the uniqueness of our position. We haven't found anything like us on this planet and not anything even remotely akin to life on other planets yet. Um, there may be more life in the universe, there probably is, but it's definitely

not abundant otherwise we wouldn't have the Fermi Paradox staring us in the face. Um, and this is sobering morally. Another one [Music] I, I do personally fear death. Yes, um, when I was a young adult working at CERN in Switzerland, I didn't, not only

because it was very remote for me back then, but because I always had this adage in my mind, where I am, death is not, where death is, I am not, so there's nothing to fear literally. Um, but as my understanding of the world and reality evolved

and I'm today as convinced as a human being can reasonably be that my consciousness will survive and witness death, I am afraid of death. Um, the best models of death we have today are high-dose psychedelic trips and they are the best because when done

in the correct settings with correct supervision, they are absolutely safe and they emulate that so well, experientially and physiologically. Psychedelics only reduce brain activity, they don't increase brain activity anywhere. A high-dose psychedelic trip in that sense is pretty much like a significant reduction

in brain metabolism, in other words, it's the process of dying. Um, and from an experiential perspective, anybody who has had a high-dose psychedelic trip entailing ego dissolution knows that it can be very difficult. Ego death is something that

you you witness it happening to you and you experience it you experience your ego just being torn apart um and and it's a frightful experience after that it's no longer frightful I I cannot speak of what comes after that but the experience is is disconcerting

is very frightful even when you know as we do during a psychedelic experience that it is temporary and reversible and will be reversed even then it's very frightful but when you're undergoing that also knowing that it's not reversible it's probably more frightful

so yes I'm I'm afraid of death but um it's a price I pay uh with a smile in my face because what I get with it is my life is Meaningful intrinsically meaningful it doesn't matter what happens it's intrinsically

meaningful um I I no longer struggle with the meaning of existence I no longer struggle with the fact that I suffer I do suffer but I am not saying oh all these sufferings for nothing why am I going through this no that that's gone I

I no longer have meta suffering I suffer like everybody a lot but no matter suffering no self-imposed suffering associated with questions of meaning and sense all of that all of those doubts it's gone for me I live in a world that is Rich and envelops me in the warm hug

of meaning and sense and I rather live like this with the fear of death um then leave an unexamined life of platitudes without fear of death

When we die and the meaning of life | dr. Bernardo Kastrup

Essentia Foundation

Materialism vs. Analytic Idealism and the Fear of Death

Materialism alleviated the fear of death by suggesting no afterlife.

The fear of death has been historically used for societal control.

Materialism eliminates the fear of an afterlife (heaven or hell).

Materialist view: 'Where death is, I am not. Where I am, death is not.'

Analytic idealism: Core objectivity persists through death.

The Reassociative Process of Death and Dreaming

Death is compared to waking from a dream; a reassociative process.

In dreams, we dissociate and identify with our dream avatar.

Upon waking, the dream avatar 'dies,' but we don't mourn it.

Life and death are hierarchical; we are alters or dissociated avatars.

Death's reaction may be similar to waking up from a dream.

Meaning in Life and Death under Analytic Idealism

Materialism eliminates the meaning of life along with the fear of death.

Analytic idealism: Insights and experiences aren't lost after death.

Suffering has meaning; experiences are released into a broader context.

Experiences remain accessible in the fabric of nature.

Remembering dreams is used as a metaphor for post-death experience.

The meaning of life is experience and learning from it.

Metacognition allows us to ask deeper questions about existence.

Life's strangeness and the search for meaning and purpose.

Metacognition exists only in life; only life can metacognize.

Life's unique position in the universe and its metacognitive ability.

Death, Sacrifice, and the Reaper Metaphor

Cultural intuitions about death often hold a kernel of truth.

Critique of human and animal sacrifice; nature should decide when life ends.

Death as the end of dissociation; insights released into nature.

Sacrifice as an offering to nature; cultural intuitions are not arbitrary.

The reaper metaphor: harvesting life's gains for the benefit of the whole.

Personal Fear of Death and Psychedelic Experiences

The speaker's personal fear of death despite previous beliefs.

Current belief: Consciousness survives death; fear of death.

High-dose psychedelic trips as models for the death experience.

Psychedelics reduce brain activity, simulating the dying process.

Ego dissolution in psychedelic trips is described as frightful.