Apple's iPhone 16 Launch: AI Controversies and Environmental Concerns

Apple's iPhone 16 launch faces controversy over generative AI features and environmental concerns, impacting user experiences across regions.

### Controversial iPhone 16 Launch: AI Features, Environmental Impact, and Regulatory Challenges
* 📱  Apple's upcoming iPhone 16 reveal is set for Monday, bringing a wave of controversy primarily due to its **new generative AI features** and their **varied availability based on location**.
* 🌍  Notably, 27 countries in the European Union will not receive the AI capabilities due to **regulatory hurdles from the Digital Markets Act**, which also affects other features like **iPhone mirroring and SharePlay**.
* ⚖️  This act aims to promote **fair competition and interoperability**, which has already influenced Apple's transition to **USB-C charging ports** and allowed Fortnite back on iPhones in the EU.
* 🌱  While Apple has made strides towards sustainability, the environmental implications of AI technology, which requires **significant computing power and electricity**, pose a challenge to its **eco-friendly narrative**.
* 💡  Research indicates that the energy consumption from AI servers could **surpass that of many small countries**, raising questions about how Apple will balance its AI ambitions with its **carbon-neutral goals by 2030**.
* 🖼️  The iOS 18.1 beta introduces a generative AI tool called "cleanup," which allows users to **erase elements from photos**, prompting **ethical concerns about the manipulation of reality** in photography.
* 📅  As the event approaches, Apple will also unveil new Apple Watches and AirPods, with the potential for **surprise announcements**, making this launch pivotal in **shaping Apple's future software and hardware dynamics**.
* 📺  Join the live stream on September 9th at 10 a.m. Pacific, 1 p.m. Eastern for insights and discussions on the **implications of this significant launch**.

[Music] Apple's next iPhone reveal is on Monday, and this is going to be a controversial Apple event. Of course, there's always a little drama when we get a new iPhone, but this time Apple's generative AI software push is making things extra spicy and unpredictable. Not everyone who buys an iPhone 16 is going to get the same features; it depends on where you live. Some people are upgrading for AI, but a lot of folks are not enthusiastic and don't want generative AI turned on. And then there's Mother Earth, who might not be too pleased with the environmental impact of Apple intelligence. With the big event almost here, let's go over the coming storm that's tied to Apple AI and what drama to watch for at this iPhone 16 launch event. I'm Bridget Carey, and this is one more thing. Apple intelligence is the big feature coming to iPhone software this year, and it's expected to be a major selling point in how Apple convinces folks to get a new iPhone because only the newest iPhones are said to be able

to run the AI, and that includes last year's top-of-the-line iPhone 15 Pro and Pro Max models. But not everyone who buys a new iPhone is getting the new AI. Apple says 27 countries in the European Union will not be getting its AI features this year. Apple says it's due to the regulatory uncertainties brought about by the Digital Markets Act. And this includes two other features: iPhone mirroring to Max and a SharePlay screen sharing feature. They're also not going to be on iPhones in the EU this year. The Digital Markets Act is antitrust regulation to promote fair competition in the EU. It requires services to work across platforms, so Apple can't favor its software over a rival company. You can thank the Digital Markets Act for putting pressure on Apple to change all of the charging ports to USB-C ports. The Digital Markets Act is what put Fortnite back on iPhones in the EU back in August of 2020. Apple removed the game Fortnite from the App Store for violations of its

payment feature, but the DMA law lets users in the EU install third-party app stores where Fortnite could be downloaded on iPhones again. This Digital Markets Act is why in Europe, iOS 18 will have a default app section where users can delete pre-installed apps. So, for example, they can take off Apple's mail app and download something else to be the default, or they can even change the defaults for the keyboard or the default app for making phone calls. But that flexibility is not in Apple's AI. Back in June, Apple sent a statement to CET saying, The interoperability requirements of the DMA could force us to compromise the integrity of our products in ways that risk user privacy and data security. Now Apple says it will work with the EU on a solution to releasing Apple intelligence in these European Union countries, but Apple also has AI drama in China. Apple's AI taps into ChatGPT, and ChatGPT is banned in China, so Apple has to find another chatbot partner just for those customers. Now we have some serious fragmentation.

of experiences. Apple has to present this phone as a worthwhile upgrade, but not every customer can experience the phone in the same way. Apple's presentations often put a big emphasis on sustainability and the environment. Last year, Apple even had this whole skit with actress Octavia Spencer as Mother Earth, pressuring Apple to be a more eco-friendly company. Everyone says they're planting trees. Apple released its first carbon-neutral product in the Apple Watch Series 9. It ended the use of leather in its product lineup, and it's cutting out plastic in its packaging. Apple is on a goal to make every product carbon-neutral by 2030. That's great, fantastic, and now one year later, how does Apple talk about the environment when it's making a big push into AI, something known for taking a toll on the environment? Scientific American reported that training and running AI systems does require a great deal of computing power and electricity. That means more carbon dioxide emissions, and it means AI contributes to The Climate crisis. Now, it's not a simple thing to calculate, but

Overall, it's not a good look, and we're starting to see some reporting on the topic, including a peer-reviewed analysis published in October about the energy footprint of artificial intelligence. Scientific American writes that Nvidia is set to ship 1.5 million AI server units by the year 2027. So, according to this research, if these servers all ran at full capacity, it would be more electricity than what many small countries use in a year. Now, that's Nvidia as the example. I'm not sure how many trees Apple would need to plant to compensate for its servers, but expect environmental critics to look at how much or how little Apple talks about its push to be more sustainable when it runs servers that power the cloud AI for millions of customers that use the most popular phone in the world. Or, you know what, maybe folks will be just so distracted by a new fine-woven case. You never know. Apple's path into AI is risky, especially when it could affect the narrative in a way that Apple can't.

control because frankly, you can't always control the quality of what AI creates. Right now, there's a developer beta of iOS 18.1 that features something called cleanup. It's a generative AI tool that lets you erase a person or object in a photo. Yes, you can erase people from existence, as Mac Rumors likes to show off in this video clip. And even though it's not fully baked, you can expect Apple to want to talk about this and other tools as a coming feature in the new batch of iPhones. Now, some folks already are comparing Apple's early beta product to the photo erasing tools in Google and Galaxy phones. Google didn't hold back its magic editor tool on the Pixel 9, which lets people add anything they want into a photo with incredible ease. So, you don't know what is real and what is fabricated without any effort put in. There's no putting the genie back in the bottle. Over at The Verge, they created something that looks like a bike accident in this photo with nothing more than a text prompt. Now, Apple no longer

has control of the narrative. We're not talking anymore about what the iPhone can do. We're looking at how Apple will handle this ethically. Gray Zone, you see when trickery becomes the selling feature. Expect critics to look at how Apple handles the messaging here in its presentation. Is Apple still talking about how the camera makes your photos look perfect, or is Apple talking about how its camera helps you alter the truth of the moment? On September 9th, Apple's going to be talking about much more than just the iPhone 16 and AI. We're expecting to hear about new Apple watches and AirPods, devices that can also tap into the power of AI. This is also when Apple could tease up new features in Apple Services. You know these iPhone events can be big productions, and you never know if there's a one more thing surprise. But to me, the biggest surprise is to see how the iPhone 16 could be the start of a new chapter in how Apple handles iPhone upgrades and events where the software might be more important than the

hardware and what happens when that software is fragmented. Depending on where you reside, we will be watching Monday when Apple streams the news at 10: a.m. Pacific, 1 p.m. Eastern time. And I'll be on CA's YouTube channel with pre-show highlights and post-show analysis. I'm joined by my CET colleague Scott Stein, so come back Monday, and I'm sure we will have plenty to talk about. Thanks for watching.

The iPhone 16 Will Tear Apple Fans Apart

CNET is the premier destination for explaining and navigating the changing world around us. Through news, product reviews, price comparisons, and more, we’ll tell you what’s new in the parts of modern life that increasingly matter more — from health, home, and money to tech, culture, and climate — and how to get the most out of them.

CNET

Controversial iPhone 16 Launch: Apple's AI Push

Apple's upcoming iPhone 16 reveal is generating drama with its focus on generative AI software, leading to uneven feature distribution based on location.

The EU's Digital Markets Act is causing Apple to withhold AI features and other updates from 27 countries, aiming to promote fair competition.

The act has also influenced Apple's decision to change charging ports to USB-C and has played a role in reinstating Fortnite on iPhones in the EU.

Apple's Challenges with AI and EU Regulations

Apple's AI features are being impacted by the EU's Digital Markets Act, which allows users to install third-party app stores and delete pre-installed apps on iPhones.

The company's AI efforts are also complicated by ChatGPT's ban in China, leading to a fragmented customer experience.

Despite Apple's push for sustainability and carbon neutrality by 2030, the environmental impact of AI's computing power and electricity usage raises concerns about its contribution to the climate crisis.

Apple's AI Server Impact and Controversial Tools

Apple's push into AI is raising environmental concerns, with Nvidia's server units potentially using more electricity than small countries by 2027.

The company's role in powering cloud AI for millions of customers using its popular phones is under scrutiny.

1 features a generative AI tool that erases people or objects from photos, drawing comparisons to similar tools from Google and raising ethical questions about the manipulation of reality.

Apple's upcoming event on September 9th will focus on more than just the iPhone 16, with expectations of new Apple watches and AirPods also being announced.

The event will be closely scrutinized for how Apple handles the ethical implications of its products, particularly in relation to AI and photo manipulation.

This iPhone launch could mark a shift in Apple's approach to upgrades and events, with software becoming more important than hardware.