Greek Philosophy: State, Women, and Music

Early Greek Philosophy and Other Essays by Friedrich Nietzsche delves into the essence of early Greek culture and its connection to art, state, music, language, and the role of women.

### Nietzsche's Insights on Early Greek Philosophy, Truth, and the State
* 🏛 Nietzsche's essays on early Greek philosophy, truth, and the state were written in the 1870s and are considered valuable fragments that contain traces of his later philosophical tenets, such as **slave and master morality** and the **Superman**.
* 👩 In "The Greek State," Nietzsche challenges modern ideas of the dignity of man and labor, arguing that the Greeks saw labor as a **necessary disgrace**, with the majority needing to toil so that a **privileged few could lead a culturally rich life**.
* ⚔ Nietzsche asserts that strife and war are necessary for the state's well-being, as **war consecrates and purifies the state**, creating the **military genius** and maintaining the **mysterious connection between the state and genius**.
* 🚺 In "The Greek Woman," Nietzsche delineates his ideal of woman as the **symbol of the future generation**, closely related to nature and having the power to **compensate for the state**. He suggests that the Hellenic woman's position was determined by the state's goals, with women like **Penelope, Antigone, and Elektra** being honored for their roles.
* 🎵 Nietzsche argues that **music is the expression of cosmic consciousness**, while language is a gesture and symbolism. He agrees with Schopenhauer that words or actions can be joined with music to provide **light and analogous occupation for the intellect**, creating a schema that **heightens the effect of music**.
* 📜 Language is seen as a symbolic representation of conceptions, with pleasure and displeasure sensations forming a **fundamental basis**. Nietzsche acknowledges the limitations of conceptions in understanding the innermost nature of things, but he distinguishes between the two main species of conceptions based on their **relation to the will**.

### The Dionysian Contest: The Relationship Between Greek Culture, Art, and the Contest of Forces
* 🏛 The Greek concept of the contest, rooted in the Dionysian spirit, was fundamental to their culture and art.
* 🥊 The contest was an essential aspect of Greek education, with individuals striving against each other to **develop their virtues and talents**.
* 🎨 In art and literature, the spirit of competition and emulation played a central role, with artists, poets, and thinkers engaging in **creative rivalries**.
* 🔥 The Dionysian impulse of the contest could be seen as a source of both **great strength** and **great danger** in Greek society.
* 🏆 The Greeks believed that **excellence could only be achieved through competition**, and that every natural gift must **develop itself through contest**.
* 🇩🇪 Nietzsche's analysis of the relationship between the Dionysian contest and German culture reflects his criticism of the **philistine narrowness and mediocrity** he saw in his contemporary society.
* 📚 German scholarship, while highly regarded, was seen by Nietzsche as a response to the **moral shortcomings and intellectual poverty** of the German character.
* The Germans, according to Nietzsche, had a tendency to resist and undermine anything that lifted them into the sublime, **pulling it down to the level of their own limitations**.

### The Tragic Age of Greek Philosophy: Thales, Anaximander, and Heraclitus
* 🌊 Thales posited that "**water is the origin and mother of all things**," making the first philosophical claim about the origin of things without using myth or allegory, and containing the idea of "**everything is one**."
* 🧐 Thales' thought, while not scientifically accurate, was driven by a **metaphysical dogma** and the **power of imagination**, which allows philosophical thinking to **leap from possibility to possibility**.
* 🌟 Thales' fellow Milesian Anaximander, in his lapidarian style, declared that "whence things originated, thither according to necessity they must return and perish," treating all becoming as an **expiation from eternal being**.
* 🕊 Anaximander's "indefinite" primordial substance, the source of all things, was a negative concept, as **something to which no predicate from the existing world could be assigned**.
* 🔮 Anaximander's questioning of the possibility of eternal becoming led him to the mystic idea of **an eternal being as the source of the world's injustice and becoming**.
* 🔥 Heraclitus saw the world as a spectacle of "**ever equal paths of justice**," denying the duality of worlds and ultimately denying "**being**" itself, proclaiming that "**i see nothing but becoming**."
* 🧠 Heraclitus possessed the highest power of intuitive conception, deriving pleasure from contradicting reason with truths gained intuitively, and his intuitive representation embraced the **ever-changing world** and the conditions of **time and space as pure concepts**.

### Parmenides and Heraclitus: Two Philosophical Giants of Ancient Greece
* 🧠 Parmenides, an ancient Greek philosopher, believed that the world of appearances was an illusion and that true reality could only be found in the **unchanging, eternal realm of "being."**
* 🔮 He concluded that "**being**" must exist because he could conceive of it, which led him to reject all sense perceptions as deceptive and to view the world of change and plurality as **mere appearance**.
* 🌌 In Parmenides' view, "being" was **indivisible, immovable, perfect, and everywhere equally present**, like a sphere. He considered it the ultimate truth that could only be **grasped through pure thought**.
* 📜 Parmenides' famous logical argument that "**what is, is; what is not, is not**" was based on the assumption that there was a separate, non-material realm of "**being**" accessible to thought.
* 🔥 On the other hand, Heraclitus, another pre-Socratic philosopher, famously proclaimed that "**everything flows**" and that **change was the fundamental nature of reality**.
* 🧩 Heraclitus used the metaphor of a river to illustrate his view that **everything was in a constant state of flux**, and he believed that **strife and opposition were the driving forces behind this continuous change**.
* 🌊 Unlike Parmenides, Heraclitus embraced the world of appearances and change, seeing it as a manifestation of a **deeper underlying unity and harmony**.
* 🤯 The contrast between Parmenides' **static, abstract view of reality** and Heraclitus' **dynamic, concrete view** highlights one of the central tensions in ancient Greek philosophy: the search for the **unchanging truth behind the ever-changing world**.

### Anaxagoras' Cosmology: The Infinite Divisibility of Being and the Motion of Mind
* 🌌 Anaxagoras posits that all things originate from all things, as he believes that if even the **contrary can originate from the contrary**, then **everything is possible**.
* 🌏 According to Anaxagoras, the names of things express only the **preponderance of one substance over others**, and originally, everything was **together and agglomerated**.
* 🌀 Anaxagoras introduces the concept of the "**chaos**," a complete, infinitely small pell-mell of all substances, as the **state of all things before all motion**.
* 🧠 The "**new**," which Anaxagoras identifies as **mind or noose**, is the cause of all motion and has the power of **free will**.
* 🌞 Anaxagoras' cosmology involves a **concentrically progressive circular motion** caused by the new, which results in the **segregation of the homogeneous substances**.
* ❓ Anaxagoras' theory raises questions about the **beginning of motion** and the nature of the **new's interaction with matter**.
* 🌌 Anaxagoras' conception of the cosmos as deriving from a **purely mechanical motion** is a **sublime and daring idea**.
* 🎭 Anaxagoras' philosophy became a kind of **free-thinking religious exercise**, with myths and gods interpreted as **hieroglyphics of nature**.

### Friedrich Nietzsche: The Nature of Truth and the Human Intellect
* 🌐 Nietzsche argues that the human intellect is a **fleeting and deceptive entity**, with cognition being merely a **momentary invention** in the vast history of the world.
* 🎭 He describes the intellect as a master of dissimulation, using language and science to build a rigid framework of ideas, but ultimately celebrating its freedom by **playfully deconstructing and rearranging these ideas**.
* 🧠 According to Nietzsche, the impulse towards truth arises from the **necessity of society to exist and function harmoniously**, with truth serving as a convention that **prevents harm**.
* 🔒 However, he contends that what is considered truth is often illusory, with **binding truths being forgotten illusions and worn-out metaphors**.
* 📏 Nietzsche sees the world as fundamentally **unknowable**, with human perceptions and ideas being **subjective and metaphorical** in nature.
* 🏛 The intellect, by volatilizing concrete perceptions into **abstract ideas**, creates a structured and orderly world that bears **little resemblance to reality**.
* 🎨 Nietzsche suggests that the human impulse for creativity and art arises from the **limitations and deceptions of the intellect**, with art providing a realm for the **free play of intuition and metaphor**.
* 😔 He contrasts the intuitive man, who lives in the realm of **culture and intuition**, with the rational man, who relies on **ideas and abstractions** to ward off misfortune and pursue happiness.

Early Greek Philosophy & Other Essays (Version 2) by Friedrich Nietzsche | Full Audio Book

Welcome to the official LibriVox YouTube channel!

LibriVox Audiobooks gives you YouTube's best library of complete audio books of works that has entered the public domain.

LibriVox objective is :
"To make all books in the public domain available, for free, in audio format on the internet". 
For more information please visit https://librivox.org/pages/about-librivox/.

All audio books has chapter selection in the video description for easier resume of listening. All books are categorized into playlists by the books author and its genres. Please browse around to find the books you enjoy and don't forget to subscribe to get a notification when new audio books becomes available.

If you want to support the channel please visit LibriVox (https://librivox.org/) that is the source of all the audio books published in the public domain. To donate to LibriVox, please visit https://librivox.org/pages/donate-to-librivox/.

LibriVox Audiobooks

Early Greek Philosophy and Other Essays: A Glimpse into Nietzsche's Thoughts

Nietzsche's essays cover a wide range of subjects, offering fragments of his later tenets and daring ideas.

The essays discuss the Greek state, the role of women in ancient Greece, the importance of music, and the concept of truth and falsity.

Nietzsche's work provides valuable insights into the early Greek philosophy and his own philosophical views, addressing the relativity of truth, the dignity of labor, and the role of the slave in shaping general conceptions.

The essays also touch on the ideal of woman, the necessity of labor for existence, and the significance of personal equation in philosophy.

The Greek Perspective on Art, Labor, and the State

The Greeks viewed the work of the artist as a necessary but somewhat shameful labor, driven by a powerful impulse to create.

They also believed that slavery was essential for the development of culture and the arts, with the majority being subjected to a life of struggle to support a privileged minority.

The Greek state was seen as a force that compelled the social process, allowing for the blossoming of artistic creation, but it was also characterized by political greed and constant internal and external conflicts.

The Role of the State and the Position of Women

The text discusses the influence of individuals who stand outside the instinct of the state, the fear of war, and the use of politics for personal gain.

It also explores Plato's conception of the position of women in relation to the state, emphasizing their role in procreation and the family.

The Hellenic woman's connection to nature, her limited rights, and her influence on art and education are also highlighted.

The Power and Position of Women in Relation to the State

Women's power and position are determined by the state's stance towards them, with their role being glorified in Greek mythology and ancient society.

The care for preservation of the species and warning prophetess role of women are invincible, especially in times of political disorder.

The relationship between music, language, and drama is discussed, highlighting the power of music to create metaphors and the unique relationship between lyric poems and music.

The Role of Music in Relation to Will and Emotion

Music is the object of the will, not the feelings, and it cannot be created directly from emotions, but can only be symbolized by them.

The lyric poet interprets music through the world of emotions, while the listener of vocal music exists only when joining in singing.

The concept of opera as a means to strengthen metaphors and conceptions is deemed an impossibility, as music can never become a mere tool for other artistic elements.

The Role of Opera in the Union of Dionysian and Apollonian

Opera is justified as a union of the Dionysian and Apollonian elements, with its highest value being good music.

The opera's dramatic music is seen as a conventional symbolism and a stimulant for the nerves, vacillating between remembrance and emotional music.

The Greek view of humanity's awful and inhuman qualities, as well as their acceptance of the impulse for strife and the pleasure of victory, sets them apart from modern ethical ideas.

The Greek Concept of Contest and Jealousy

The Greek concept of contest and jealousy is seen as a driving force for action and ambition, rather than as a negative quality.

In Greek culture, the idea of competition was linked to the welfare of the civic society, and individuals were encouraged to strive for the benefit of their community.

The Greeks believed that the contest was essential for the development of natural gifts and to prevent autocracy, fearing the dangers of unchecked genius.

The Role of Philosophy in the Health of a Nation

Philosophical systems are only absolutely true to their founders and are often disapproved of by later philosophers.

The history of earlier Greek philosophers is an attempt to bring to light the irrefutable and indiscussible elements of their personalities.

Philosophy is justified by the Greeks as a truly healthy nation, as they have philosophized more than any other, teaching a valuable lesson on when one ought to begin philosophizing.

The Birth of Greek Philosophy and its Impact

Greek philosophy originated in a time of prosperity and victory, rather than in hardship, shedding light on the nature of both philosophy and the Greeks themselves.

The early Greek philosophers, from Thales to Socrates, formed a unique and integral community, devoting their lives exclusively to knowledge and paving the way for future generations of thinkers.

The loss of many complete works of these early philosophers has deprived us of a sublime part of Greek thought, impacting the understanding of their true significance.

Greek philosophy started with the idea that water is the origin of all things, attributed to Thales.

Thales' proposition marked the beginning of natural philosophy and the concept of unity.

The philosopher's use of metaphysical dogma and intuition to make generalizations demonstrated the power of philosophical thinking.

Anaximander's Ethical and Metaphysical Inquiry

Anaximander questions the fundamental nature of human existence, seeing it as a form of punishment that needs to be atoned for.

He delves into the ethical problem of why anything that has the right to exist must perish and explores the concept of the primordial being as indefinite, superior to all becoming.

Anaximander's deep shadows of world perception and mystic possibilities are further illuminated by Heraclitus, who emphasizes the justification of becoming and denies the duality of two diverse worlds, ultimately focusing on the eternal and exclusive nature of becoming.

Heraclitus' Concept of the Universe and the Struggle of Opposites

Heraclitus believed in the struggle of opposite forces as the driving factor of all existence, seeing it as a manifestation of eternal justice.

He introduced the idea of fire as the primary world-shaping force, continuously transforming into other elements in a cyclical process.

His philosophy centered around the innocence and playfulness of this cosmic struggle, free from moral bias and guilt.

Heraclitus and Parmenides: Two Philosophical Perspectives

Heraclitus believes in the necessity and unchangeability of the world, finding order and security in the process of becoming, while Parmenides divides the world into the realm of being and the realm of becoming, focusing on the classification of positive and negative qualities.

Both philosophers struggle with the contrast between the two world orders and the leap from the empirical to the indefinite, with Heraclitus embracing the world's becoming and Parmenides seeking to classify its qualities.

Parmenides' Concept of Unity and Existence

Parmenides had a unique logical approach, dividing the world into positive and negative qualities, and emphasizing the necessity of cooperation between the existent and the non-existent for becoming.

His encounter with Xenophanes led to a fundamental shift in his thinking, causing him to question the existence of negative qualities.

This led him to the invention of a principle based on tautological truth, ultimately shaping his concept of the existent as indivisible and perfect.

Parmenides rejected the separation of mind and body, believing that all sense perceptions were illusions and that the material of thinking is brought in from an extra-material world.

He also introduced the idea of the infinite, using indirect proof to argue that motion and plurality were ultimately illusions.

Parmenides ascribed to the idea that thinking and being were identical, rejecting any duality of being and celebrating the triumph of the mind over the claims of the senses.

Parmenides' philosophy of the identity of being and thinking is challenged through two main arguments: the reality of motion and plurality, and the unanswered question of the origin of appearance.

Anaxagoras opposes Parmenides by asserting the truth of motion and succession, as demonstrated by the succession of conceptions in thinking, and by arguing that the unequal cannot come from the equal.

Additionally, Anaxagoras' belief in a plurality of substances and the concept of infinity is shown to be in contradiction and driven into flight by Parmenides' proposition of the one being.

The Incoherent Theories of Parmenides and Anaxagoras

Parmenides' theory of "being" suggests that existence is contradictory and impossible, while Anaxagoras' concept of the "chaos" is based on inadequate induction from natural phenomena.

Parmenides argues that the perception of succession and change is illusory, while Anaxagoras believes that all things contain all substances and that preponderance is gradually produced through motion.

Anaxagoras' chaotic conception is a result of his observations of evolution in nature, leading to the belief that everything can originate from everything.

The Concept of Becoming and Motion in Anaxagoras' Philosophy

Anaxagoras' theory suggests that all things were originally in a complete state of mixture, with the process of segregation taking an infinite amount of time.

He believes that the motion of the mind is the driving force behind the segregation of substances and the creation of the cosmos.

The concept of motion in Anaxagoras' philosophy is characterized by a circular movement, with different types of matter being separated as a result.

The Philosophy of Anaxagoras and Its Critique by Empedocles

Anaxagoras viewed the world as being formed by the irrational and arbitrary motion of the "nous," or mind, while his philosophy was a blend of free-thinking religious exercise and natural science.

He believed in the free will of the mind to initiate motion, in contrast to the mechanical determinism that governed the rest of the world.

Empedocles critiqued Anaxagoras' ideas, emphasizing the principle of economy and critiquing the complexity of Anaxagoras' assumptions, particularly regarding the concept of motion and segregation in the world.

Empedocles proposed his own ideas about the forces of love and hatred, as well as the principles of attraction and repulsion, to explain the formation and stability of the world, in contrast to Anaxagoras' theories.

The Pessimistic View of Human Intellect in Nature

The human intellect is seen as purposeless and fleeting in nature, with a haughty attitude towards existence.

It is described as a tool for deception and dissimulation, leading to a shallow understanding of truth.

The desire for truth is driven by its life-preserving consequences and the avoidance of harmful deception, rather than a genuine love for pure knowledge.

Language is described as a system of metaphors and arbitrary designations, with words being inadequate expressions of the true essence of things.

The formation of ideas is based on the equating of unequal experiences, leading to the creation of abstract concepts.

Truth is seen as a product of human relations and societal obligations, giving rise to a moral emotion related to truth.

The Power of Language and Science in Shaping Human Perception

The construction of ideas is originally influenced by language and later by science, shaping the way humans perceive the world.

Science continuously works to organize and renew perceptions, while the human impulse for metaphors and art creates a constantly changing and dream-like interpretation of reality.

The rational and intuitive man coexist, with the intuitive man's use of metaphors and dissimulation leading to a different experience of suffering and happiness.