Apple's 2014 Event: YouTube Album and iPhone 6 Controversies

Apple's 2014 event is remembered for its blunders, especially the forced U2 album download, sparking widespread frustration.

### Reflecting on Apple's Memorable September 2014 Event: A Decade of Debacles
* 📅  Ten years ago, on September 9th, 2014, Apple made headlines for an event that was marked by several significant missteps, including the **controversial automatic addition of a U2 album to iPhones**.
* 📱  This event also introduced the iPhone 6, which was notable for its **two sizes** and the emergence of "**Bendgate**," where users reported the phone **bending under pressure** due to its **thin design**.
* 🔄  Additionally, the iPhone 6 launch was marred by a problematic iOS 8 update that led to further issues, prompting Apple to **advise users against downloading updates immediately**.
* ⌚  The Apple Watch was unveiled, marketed as a **luxury item with prices soaring up to $17,000**, but it ultimately failed to resonate as a **long-lasting heirloom product**.
* 💳  Tim Cook introduced Apple Pay, which promised to **replace wallets**, but even a decade later, it struggles with **widespread adoption**, particularly at major retailers like Home Depot and Walmart.
* 🎶  The infamous U2 album stunt left many users **confused and frustrated**, resulting in Bono's public apology and a shift in how Apple approached **media distribution**.
* 🎧  Reflecting on the evolution of music consumption, the landscape has changed dramatically from **ownership to streaming**, leading to a growing interest in physical music devices like **iPods once again**.
* 🔍  As we anticipate the upcoming iPhone 16 event, it's a reminder of how **much has changed in the tech world** and the lessons learned from that **fateful day in 2014**.

when Apple holds an event, it makes history. But when you look back on all Apple has done, I am fascinated by one singular Apple event that happened 10 years ago. A lot went wrong, and nothing like it will ever happen again. I'm talking about September 9th, 2014, the day Apple shoved a You2 album on everyone's iPhone. But YouTu was not the only debacle to come from that beautiful day. This was the iPhone 6 event, which gave us Ben gate and a botched iOS release. It was the debut of the Apple Watch, pitched as a luxury item costing as much as 17 grand for the fanciest of Fancy Pants customers. This also was when Tim Cook introduced Apple Pay with the bold promise of replacing your wallet. News flash: we still need wallets. But most folks just remember it as the day when Apple installed a YouTu album on every device, whether you wanted it or not, and it off so many people. I'll get more into that, but so many things went wrong around this iPhone launch.

that we have to talk about it so as we get ready for the iPhone 16 and the watch 10 event in just a few weeks. Here's one more thing: let's look back on the awkward moments from the iPhone 6 event and how much has changed in the decade since. I'm Bridget Cary, and this is one more thing. The iPhone 6 was the first time Apple had the iPhone in two sizes. There was an iPhone 6 and a 6 Plus. It measured in at 5.5 inches. Now, that's totally not a plus size by today's standards. The plus size screen is now 6.7 inches in diameter. The iPhone 6 also was one of the thinnest iPhones, which turns out might have caused some problems shortly after its release. Some folks reported that the phone casing would bend under pressure, like if it's in a tight pants pocket, and that gave us the term Bendgate. At the time, Apple said bent iPhones were extremely rare, but surely no phone was thinner ever since the 6, perhaps

Apple didn't want another Bend gate, but we could be going back to super thin designs. Rumor has it that Apple is working on a slim iPhone 17. Now, Apple analyst Ming-Chi Kuo says it would have a mixed titanium-aluminum frame for strength and just have one camera on the back. And we might say goodbye to the plus size altogether for next year. Now, some are saying this new model could be 5 mm thin. That would make it the thinnest iPhone ever. So, 10 years after the iPhone 6 Plus, we could be going back to something that looks like the iPhone 6 Plus. Bend gate was a rough time because it came right as Apple was recovering from a bad iOS 8 update. A week after iOS 8 released, Apple pushed out version 8.0.1 to fix some bugs, but it came with bigger bugs, and it borked some iPhones. Users reported that it was breaking cellular reception, with the iPhone showing no service on the display, and others noticed problems with Touch

ID Apple had to pull back the update. This event made reporters like me warn people to never download an Apple update on the first day it comes out. I still get weird about downloading iOS updates right away. The following year, in 2015, Apple opened up the iOS beta program to the public for the first time. Perhaps it's one way Apple makes sure it doesn't have another problematic update like that again. When Tim Cook introduced the Apple Watch, it wouldn't reach consumer wrists for another 7 months. There was a lot of time to wait and speculate. Folks were wondering, Why do you even need a smartwatch? Apple was marketing this in many different ways. You see, Apple wanted it to be for both runners and the high-end fashion crowd. Remember, at this point, every tech company was making smartwatches, so Apple went all out on the luxury angle to stand apart. There were three versions: the entry-level aluminum and glass watch sport model. It started at about $350. There was a stainless steel version that started at roughly $550. But the Big Daddy was the Apple

watch Edition, a luxury model made of 18 karat gold, starting price was $10,000, and it went up to 17 grand. Vogue gave it a 12-page cover spread, but here's the thing: unlike a real luxury watch, computer screens are not an heirloom. You can't pass this down to your kids, so it was a doomed idea, and it flopped. It did in fact become obsolete. Apple will no longer fix it, and the software has not been updated beyond watch OS 4.3.2. That's back in 2018. A decade later, we still have three versions, and the luxury aspect is really about which wrist WP you buy. Here's sells a band for $590, more than the cost of buying two Apple watches. But all those fashion bands might as well head to the landfill. The 10th edition of the Apple watch is rumored to have a whole new design with a new system for connecting the bands. So these current bands that just kind of slide in and out of the slot here.

they're likely incompatible. Will people be quick to upgrade if they're losing all of their investment on the bands? I mean, at least when I buy a new pair of pants, the belt I bought is still compatible. Apple Pay was introduced as a way to replace the wallet, but not every retailer was playing along at first. Stores like Home Depot and Walmart did not take Apple Pay, and 10 years later, you still can't use it at Home Depot or Walmart. But many other retailers did eventually get on board, and it seems to be almost everywhere. I can pay for the New York City subway by just tapping my iPhone now, but it still struggles to be a wallet replacement because of driver's licenses. Only some states are compatible with putting their licenses in the Apple Wallet, so wallets are not dead. If you're like me and you love those wild Loungefly wallets, you can still keep buying them with Apple Pay. Ironically, that September event was jam-packed, and it was a live event, which sadly I think is something Apple won't

do again but even with all of this news. Tim Cook wanted one more thing to close out the gather in a celebratory moment for the iTunes Store, which at this point was around for a decade. The band YouTube performs this new song for the crowd, and then Bono gets on stage with Cook to tease up that Apple should pay him to give this whole album to every iTunes customer if we gave it away for free. But first, you would have to pay for it 'cause we're not going in for the free music around here. And with that magic instant, everyone got Songs of Innocence on their machines, and then everyone was left confused on how to remove Songs of Innocence from their machines. If you don't follow Apple news, I guess you just woke up and you were like, Uh, what is Bono doing on my iPhone? Now, I'm old enough to remember when devices came with free media all the time. Windows 95 came with a free movie file of the Weezer Buddy Holly music video, and one of the earliest Samsung Galaxy phones it

was called the Samsung Vibrant on T-Mobile in 2010. It came with an entire copy of the Avatar movie loaded on it, and I swear to you that's how I watched Avatar for the first time on a 4-inch screen, just like how James Cameron wanted. But back to Bono. Although it was a free thing, and Americans love free things, they do not love having this music appear on their machines because it was so woven in with their iTunes music library. It was in the iCloud, and you couldn't just delete it out of the iCloud, at least not at first. Like if you just shuffled, you had U2 suddenly playing. It was so bad that Bono apologized for the stunt, and Apple had to provide a whole fix just to help people remove it. It went so poorly that I don't think we're going to get a free piece of media again unless you count free trials of subscriptions because now so much has shifted to streaming services. And think about how much is different from a decade ago in music ownership. We had MP3 libraries and iPods.

and then they took away our CD drives, and I guess you could buy an external CD drive, but not anymore an apple because the super Drive is no longer available. As of just a few weeks ago, we had this method of buying and storing music, but the environment changed around this method, so I don't blame consumers. Ownership just became obsolete when the infrastructure of ownership changed. Now, doing this story made me realize that my digital music library over the years is just rotting on some drive somewhere because I stream everything, anything. I realize it's been years since I purchased any song, and that kind of freaked me out because you don't really own anything if the digital rights to a song you love leaves a streaming service. It's a bit of a mission now to get mp3s and figure out where it all lives and how to move files around, but there is still a desire with customers for some sort of physical device that you can take music with you and also let you disconnect. Just look at Urban Outfitters.

It is selling old iPods. The company Retro ECT refurbishes old iPods, and it inspired me to get back to our past, so I bought one. This is a first-generation iPod Mini from 2004. I'm going to play around with this a bit, and I'm going to report later on what it's like going back to just a simple MP3 player, even when iTunes software really isn't a thing anymore. Let me know what you're looking for in the next iPhone event, or let me know if you have any experience going back to iPods. But even if you don't comment, I'll still do a show about it with or without you. Thanks for watching. I'll catch you next Friday for one more thing.

Decade Before iPhone 16, Apple’s Big Blunders: U2, Bendgate, Botched iOS 8

CNET is the premier destination for explaining and navigating the changing world around us. Through news, product reviews, price comparisons, and more, we’ll tell you what’s new in the parts of modern life that increasingly matter more — from health, home, and money to tech, culture, and climate — and how to get the most out of them.

CNET

The September 9th, 2014 Apple event is remembered for its controversial You2 album installation on every iPhone.

This event also marked the launch of the iPhone 6, which faced issues like Bendgate and a botched iOS release.

Additionally, Apple introduced the Apple Watch and Apple Pay, but the event is primarily remembered for the backlash from the album giveaway.

Apple's Potential iPhone 17 Design and Impact

Apple is rumored to be working on a slim iPhone 17 with a mixed titanium-aluminum frame and just one camera, potentially making it the thinnest iPhone ever at 5 mm.

The company may also be phasing out the plus size model for next year.

This design shift comes after the challenges faced during the iPhone 6 Plus era and Apple's problematic iOS 8 update, which led to the public beta program and a more cautious approach to software updates.

The Apple Watch Edition, made of 18 karat gold, had a starting price of $10,000 but ultimately failed due to its lack of heirloom value.

The luxury aspect of the watch was lost with the high-priced bands, and the 10th edition is rumored to have a completely new design, making the current bands incompatible.

Apple Pay also struggled to replace traditional wallets, with inconsistent retailer participation and limited compatibility for driver's licenses.

Tim Cook celebrated the iTunes Store's decade anniversary by bringing Bono on stage to offer U2's "Songs of Innocence" for free to all iTunes customers, causing confusion as the album instantly appeared on their devices.

The unexpected gift led to frustration for users trying to remove the album, as it was intertwined with their iTunes music library and iCloud.

The backlash was so significant that Bono apologized, and Apple had to implement a fix to help users remove the album, marking a shift away from offering free media.

The Shift from CD Drives to Digital Music

Apple's SuperDrive is no longer available, making it harder to buy and store music on physical devices.

The author's digital music library has become obsolete as they now rely solely on streaming services.

There is still a demand for physical music devices, leading the author to buy a first-generation iPod Mini from 2004 and explore the experience of using a simple MP3 player again.