Understanding Chesterton's Fence

Understanding the purpose before reforming is crucial for avoiding unintended consequences in decision-making processes.

### Chesterton's Fence: The Principle of Understanding Before Reform
* 🚧 Chesterton's Fence is a rule of thumb advising against **destroying a fence, changing a rule, or discarding a tradition without understanding why it exists**.
* 💡 The principle assumes that fences were erected for a purpose, involved **careful planning**, and cost **time and resources** to build.
* 💸 In a real-world example, a startup CFO's attempt to cut costs by **charging employees for free snacks** led to negative consequences, as employees disliked the change and some even **quit**.
* 🐦 A tragic case of misguided reform was China's Great Leap Forward's Four Pests Campaign, which unintentionally led to the **near-extinction of sparrows** and a subsequent **locust swarm** that contributed to the **Great Chinese Famine**.
* 📜 Chesterton's original 1929 writing emphasizes the principle of **understanding before reform**, stating that reformers should not **destroy something unless they understand its purpose**.
* ❓ The text raises the question of whether Chesterton's defense of conservatism, requiring **understanding before changing existing structures**, is a good rule to follow, or if there are situations where it is necessary to **break down old structures without full comprehension**.
* 💬 Readers are invited to share their thoughts on whether they believe in Chesterton's principle or if they think there are instances where it is necessary to **dismantle old structures without complete understanding**.
* Support for the creators of the video lessons that explain complex ideas through simple cartoon animations is available at **patreon.com/sprouts**, and parents or educators can find additional resources and classroom activities at **sproutsschools.com**.

Suppose there is a fence erected in the middle
of nowhere that’s blocking your path: what do you do? Do you take it down in order to
continue on your way? Or do you first think hard about why it is there to begin with? Chesterton's Fence is a simple rule of thumb
that suggests that you should never destroy a fence, change a rule, or do away with a
tradition until you understand why it’s there in the first place. The principle assumes that fences have a purpose,
were carefully planned, and cost time and money to erect. Someone must have had a reason
for thinking that a fence would be a good idea. So what if we just take them down? Entrepreneur Steve Blank likes to point out
that when startups get their first Chief Financial Officer, the newly hired often wants to show
that they are proactive and cut costs. Some go as far as calculating the expense of the
free snacks offered to employees and then

start charging the staff a small fee. People can, of course, pay, but they don’t
like this change in company culture — and many may quit. As a result, the firm makes
pennies on the nuts but spends thousands hiring new engineers. All because the reformer didn’t
understand the purpose of the policy he axed. A more tragic example of misguided reform
was China’s so-called Great Leap Forward, which lasted from 1958 to 1962. One of
its initiatives was the Four Pests Campaign to eliminate all mosquitoes, flies, rats,
and even sparrows that were suspected of stealing grain from the fields. And so millions of people hit noisy pots and
pans to prevent sparrows from resting, with the goal of causing them to drop dead from
exhaustion. Some simply shot the birds down from the sky. Others destroyed their nests
and broke their eggs. The campaign worked and pushed the Chinese
sparrow population to near extinction. So

what about the unintended consequences? With no sparrows to eat them, locust populations
ballooned, swarming the country and compounding the problems caused by other reforms. The
consequence was the Great Chinese Famine, one of the largest man-made disasters in human
history, with a death toll in the tens of millions. Perhaps all those who want 
to break with traditions,  or reform norms, should learn to recite this short line from philosopher F. K. Chesterton's
original 1929 writing: “In the matter of reforming things, as distinct
from deforming them, there is one plain and simple principle.” Let us say, for the sake of simplicity, a
fence or gate is erected across a road. The more modern type of reformer goes up to it
and says, 'I don't see the use of this; let us clear it away.' To which, the more intelligent
type of reformer will do well to answer:

'If you don't see the use of it, I certainly
won't let you clear it away. Go away and think. Then, when you can come back and tell me that
you do see the use of it, I may allow you to destroy it.” What do you think? Is Chesterton's defense
of conservatism a good rule to live by? Or do you also need people to break down old
structures even if they don’t fully understand why they were built in the first place? Share
your thoughts in the comments below! If you like how we explain complicated ideas
in simple cartoon animation, you can support us. Visit patreon.com/sprouts. Just visit
us, learn how it works, and what’s in it for you. We hope to see you there! And if you are a parent,  or an educator, check our 
website sproutsschools.com. There you can find this and other video lessons,
additional resources, and classroom activities.

Chesterton Fence: Don’t Destroy What You Don’t Understand!

We create cartoons that explain complicated ideas in simple language. We publish our video lessons with a Creative Commons license, so teachers at public schools or nonprofits can use them in classrooms free of charge. 

To support our work join us on https://patreon.com/sprouts.
For classroom activities, or to download our videos without background music, go to https://sproutsschools.com. 
To participate in topic selection, join our community on discord: https://discord.gg/DzbyGSk5y8

Sprouts channels in other languages:
Spanish: https://www.youtube.com/@UCf_PS8-T1w_VT1Kz-9G0nHw 
German: https://www.youtube.com/@UCACKzLYxdIRKEcWqiA3o-BQ 
Chinese: https://www.youtube.com/@UCbWqAbkBTmfnB8uo78ttVcw 
Russian: https://www.youtube.com/@UCrQkGkkhUP5vPlOZ0Excn0Q 
French: https://www.youtube.com/@UCGj6ZcECjYQtmPJNzV8jYtw 
Italian: https://www.youtube.com/@UCpiI2N_0GZQ63OL3VK4lHXg 
Thai: https://www.youtube.com/@UCjbGGEmXBRH3hCYGNEgQXfQ 

To see all, visit https://sproutsschools.com. 


Sprouts

Chesterton's Fence is a rule that advises against removing a fence, changing a rule, or abandoning a tradition without understanding its purpose.

This principle is often overlooked, as seen in the actions of some startup CFOs who made changes without grasping the impact on company culture.

The devastating consequences of not understanding the purpose of a system are also demonstrated in China's Great Leap Forward, particularly in the Four Pests Campaign, which led to the near extinction of the Chinese sparrow population.

The Unintended Consequences of Sparrow Elimination in China

The elimination of sparrows in China led to a drastic increase in locust populations, contributing to the Great Chinese Famine.

The famine, caused by a series of reforms, resulted in the death of tens of millions of people.

Chesterton's philosophy on reform urges a careful consideration of the potential consequences, highlighting the need for thoughtful and informed decision-making.

Chesterton's Defense of Conservatism and the Need for Change

Chesterton's defense of conservatism emphasizes the importance of understanding the use of existing structures before destroying them.

However, there is also a need for people to challenge old systems, even without full comprehension, in order to drive progress.

Sprouts offers simple cartoon animations to explain complex ideas and welcomes support on patreon.